Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Molecular and Cellular Biology, November 2002, p. 8067-8078, Vol. 22, No. 22
0270-7306/02/$04.00+0 DOI: 10.1128/MCB.22.22.8067-8078.2002
Copyright © 2002, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
Howard Hughes Medical Institute, Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, Cold Spring Harbor, New York 11724
Received 22 May 2002/ Returned for modification 9 July 2002/ Accepted 14 August 2002
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
The human U6 snRNA promoter is a type 3 RNA polymerase III promoter characterized by gene-external promoter elements, which can be divided into enhancer and core regions. The enhancer region, referred to as the distal sequence element, is located about 200 bp upstream of the transcription start site and contains binding sites for the POU domain protein Oct-1 and the zinc finger protein STAF (see reference 7 for a review). Both of these factors can activate U6 transcription and can be localized to the U6 promoter region in vivo by chromatin immunoprecipitation experiments (14, 20-22, 26, 28, 35).
The U6 core promoter region consists of a proximal sequence element (PSE) and a TATA box located about 50 and 25 bp, respectively, upstream of the transcription start site. The PSE recruits the snRNA-activating protein complex (SNAPc), a complex consisting of five types of subunits, SNAP190, SNAP50, SNAP45, SNAP43, and SNAP19 (reference 5 and references therein). Of these subunits, the largest (SNAP190) contains an unusual Myb domain with a half Myb repeat (Rh) followed by four full-length Myb repeats (Ra, Rb, Rc, and Rd), of which the last two are required for DNA binding of the complex (19, 32). The TATA box recruits TBP (7). TBP is one component of the TFIIIB activity, which for 5S- and tRNA-type promoters also contains the SANT domain protein Bdp1 (previously called human B') and the TFIIB-related factor Brf1 (4, 16, 25, 30). Basal transcription from the human U6 promoter requires a specialized TFIIIB activity in which the Brf1 protein is replaced by another TFIIB-related factor known as Brf2 (previously called BRFU or TFIIIB50 [25, 29]; for a universal nomenclature of TFIIIB subunits, see reference 31).
All of the U6 promoter elements are required for stable assembly of a U6 transcription initiation complex (11), which presumably depends on a number of protein-protein interactions among members of the complex. One such interaction mediates cooperative binding of the transcription activator Oct-1 and the basal factor SNAPc and involves a glutamate residue at position 7 within the Oct-1 POU domain and a lysine at position 900 within SNAP190 (2, 17). In the natural U6 promoter, this protein-protein contact is mediated by a positioned nucleosome that brings the octamer sequence in close proximity to the PSE (35). A subcomplex of SNAPc called mini-SNAPc, which consists of SNAP43, SNAP50, and the N-terminal third of SNAP190, cannot bind cooperatively with Oct-1 because it lacks the SNAP190 region containing the critical lysine residue at position 900. Surprisingly, however, mini-SNAPc binds more efficiently to a PSE than the full-length SNAPc, suggesting that the full-length complex contains a built-in damper that down-regulates its binding to DNA and that is deleted in mini-SNAPc (19).
In addition to the interaction between the activator Oct-1 and SNAPc, protein-protein contacts are likely to occur among core promoter binding factors, because they also display cooperative binding. For example, TBP and Brf2 bind cooperatively to a TATA box (1), and SNAPc and TBP bind cooperatively to probes containing both a PSE and a TATA box (18). We have shown that mini-SNAPc, although unable to bind cooperatively with the Oct-1 POU domain, can bind cooperatively with TBP (19). Because mini-SNAPc binds relatively efficiently to DNA on its own, cooperative binding in this case results, in effect, in recruitment of TBP to the DNA (19).
Here we have assembled complexes that were smaller than mini-SNAPc (stmSNAPc) and tested their ability to recruit TBP to the DNA. The results identify a 50-amino-acid (aa) region within the N-terminal part of SNAP190 that is required for cooperative binding of mini-SNAPc with TBP. When fused to the RcRd repeats of SNAP190 or the GAL4 DNA binding domain, this region is sufficient to recruit TBP to a TATA box. By using stmSNAPcs lacking the TBP-recruiting region, we show that there are at least two redundant mechanisms to recruit TBP to U6 transcription initiation complexes. Our results also identify a stmSNAPc that is 192 aa smaller than mini-SNAPc and yet is still capable of directing basal RNA polymerase III transcription.
|
|
|---|
Electrophoretic mobility shift assays (EMSAs). The binding reactions were performed in a total volume of 20 µl containing 80 mM KCl, 20 mM HEPES (pH 7.9), 5 mM MgCl2, 0.2 mM EDTA, 10% glycerol, 1 mM dithiothreitol (DTT), 0.07% Tween 20, 0.5 µg of poly(dG-dC) · (dG-dC), 0.25 µg of pUC118, and 20 µg of fetal bovine serum. The reaction mixtures were incubated for 20 min at 4°C before addition of the radiolabeled probe, followed by a 30-min incubation at 30°C. The binding reactions were fractionated on a 5% polyacrylamide gel (39:1 acrylamide-bisacrylamide) in TGEM buffer (50 mM Tris base, 380 mM glycine, 2 mM EDTA, 5 mM MgCl2). The probes used in Fig. 5 had the sequence 5' CATTTCTCT ATCGATAGGT ACCGGAGGAC TGTCCTCCGC GGAGGACTGT CCTCCGCGGA GGACTGTCCT CCGGCTGCATATAAGCAGCT GCTTTTTCTC GAGTACTGG 3', in which the three G17 GAL4 binding sites (3) are underlined and the TATA box is indicated in bold type. The italicized AT in the TATA box was changed to GG in the probe carrying a mutated TATA box.
![]() View larger version (72K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 5. SNAP190 aa 1 to 90 can recruit TBP to the DNA when fused to a heterologous DNA binding domain. (A) The structures of the various fusion proteins are illustrated. HT, His Tag. (B) EMSA performed with probes containing three tandem copies of the G17 GAL4 DNA binding site (3 X G17) (3) inserted 5 bp upstream of the wild-type (lanes 1 to 14) or mutated (lanes 15 to 20) HIV-1 TATA box (see Materials and Methods for the sequences of the probes), and the proteins indicated above the lanes. The presence (+) or absence (-) of TBP and the amounts (indicated by the thickness of the triangle) of the proteins containing the GAL4 DNA binding domain (DBD) are shown over the gel. DBD, GAL4 DBD-HT; (1-90)DBD, (1-90)GAL4 DBD-HT (see panel A). Both the GAL4 DBD-HT and (1-90)GAL4 DBD-HT proteins were titrated over a threefold range. In lanes 17 and 18, the same amount of GAL4 DBD-HT was used as in lane 5. In lanes 19 and 20, the same amount of (1-90)GAL4 DBD-HT was used as in lane 11. The proteins present in the various protein-DNA complexes are indicated to the left of the panels.
|
|
|
|---|
![]() View larger version (31K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. Composition of various SNAPc subcomplexes. (A) Map of the known subunit-subunit interactions within SNAPc. Within SNAP190, aa 84 to 133 associate with SNAP19 and aa 164 to 268 of SNAP43, aa 263 to 503 correspond to the Myb domain with the Rh, Ra, Rb, Rc, and Rd repeats, aa 869 to 912 correspond to the Oct-1-interacting region (OIR), and aa 1281 to 1393 associate with SNAP45. Within SNAP43, aa 1 to 164 associate with SNAP50. Mini-SNAPc contains SNAP190 aa 1 to 514, SNAP43, and SNAP50, as outlined in red. (B) The composition of each stmSNAPc is indicated. All stmSNAPcs including stmSNAPc#23-26 contain a SNAP190 protein truncated after aa 505.
|
![]() View larger version (87K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. A 50-aa region of SNAP190 is required for cooperative binding of the complex with TBP. (A) EMSA performed with the proteins indicated above the lanes and a probe containing the wild-type mouse U6 PSE and either the wild-type or a mutated human U6 TATA box as indicated above the lanes. In panels A to C, the upper complex in the doublet observed with stmSNAPc#1 (#1) is labeled with an asterisk to the left of the complex, and the upper complex of the doublet observed with stmSNAPc#1 and TBP is labeled with an arrowhead to the left of the complex. -190, anti-SNAP190 antibody; -, only complex #1 was added. (B) EMSA performed with the proteins indicated above the lanes and a probe containing the wild-type mouse U6 PSE and the human U6 TATA box. The absence (-) or presence of the stmSNAPc proteins (indicated by the stmSNAPc number) is indicated over the lanes. The absence (-) and amount (indicated by the height of the triangle) of TBP is indicated over the gel. TBP was titrated over a threefold range. The protein-DNA complexes containing the stmSNAPcs only or both the stmSNAPcs and TBP are indicated. (C) EMSA performed with the proteins indicated above the lanes and a probe containing a wild-type mouse U6 PSE and a mutated TATA box. The presence or absence (-) and the amount (indicated by the height of the triangle over the lanes) of TBP are indicated over the lanes.
|
Deletion of the N-terminal 32 aa of SNAP190 had no effect on TBP recruitment (stmSNAPc#3; Fig. 2B, lanes 11 and 12); however, deletion of the first 62 aa weakened TBP recruitment (stmSNAPc#5; lanes 17 and 18), and deletion of the first 83 aa resulted in a barely detectable stmSNAPc-TBP complex (stmSNAPc#7; lanes 23 and 24). This suggested that a region required for cooperative binding with TBP lay between SNAP190 aa 63 (or slightly N-terminal of aa 63) and aa 84. Surprisingly, however, an internal deletion encompassing aa 50 to 83 of SNAP190 had little effect (stmSNAPc#25; lanes 35 and 36), and only a larger internal deletion from aa 34 to 83 reduced cooperative binding significantly (stmSNAPc#23; lanes 29 and 30). Combination of the SNAP190 deletions with deletion of the last 100 aa of SNAP43 had little additional effect on cooperative binding with TBP (compare each odd-numbered complex with the next even-numbered complex). Together, these results indicate that in the context of mini-SNAPc, the SNAP190 region extending from aa 34 to 83 contains redundant sequences required for cooperative binding with TBP.
When we tested whether cooperative binding is dependent on a wild-type PSE and TATA box, we did not detect binding of the stmSNAPcs to probes containing a mutant PSE, consistent with our previous results (13), even upon addition of TBP (data not shown). The results with a probe containing a wild-type mouse U6 PSE and a mutant TATA box for all of the stmSNAPcs are shown in Fig. 2C. As before for stmSNAPc#1 (Fig. 2A), we did not observe any of the stmSNAPc-TBP complexes in the absence of the TATA box, indicating that cooperative binding is dependent on both an intact PSE and an intact TATA box, as observed previously (18). However, for all stmSNAPcs containing full-length SNAP43, we did observe formation of the upper complex of the doublet upon addition of TBP (Fig. 2C, lanes 4, 8, 12, 16, 20, and 24, complex labeled with an asterisk). As shown above, the mobility of this complex was not affected by replacing TBP with a larger GST-TBP fusion protein or with Brf2 (Fig. 2A, compare lanes 16 and 17), again suggesting that it corresponds to another conformation of the stmSNAPcs.
The N-terminal 90 aa of SNAP190 are sufficient for cooperative binding with TBP when fused to the SNAP190 RcRd Myb repeats. The above results suggest that in a complex consisting of SNAP43 (or the first 268 aa of SNAP43), SNAP50, and the N-terminal third of SNAP190, the N terminus of SNAP190 is required for cooperative binding with TBP. To determine whether this SNAP190 region might recruit TBP in the absence of other SNAPc subunits, we fused it via a six-glycine linker to either the N [(1-90)RcRd] or C [RcRd(1-90)] terminus of the RcRd repeats of SNAP190 (Fig. 3A). The SNAP190 RcRd repeats can bind to the PSE on their own, as visualized with a gel lacking MgCl2, although with reduced specificity (32; M. Wong and N. Hernandez, unpublished results). As illustrated in Fig. 3A, we also generated a protein consisting of just the N-terminal 90 aa of SNAP190. All the constructs carried a His tag (HT) for easy purification from E. coli lysates.
![]() View larger version (61K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. When fused to the SNAP190 RcRd Myb repeats, SNAP190 aa 1 to 90 are sufficient to recruit TBP to a TATA box. (A) The structures of the various fusion proteins are illustrated. HT, His tag; G6, a run of six glycines. (B) EMSA performed with probes containing either wild-type or mutated mouse U6 PSE and wild-type or mutated human U6 TATA box, as indicated above the panels, and the proteins indicated above the lanes. The absence (-) or presence (+) of TBP is indicated over the gel. TBP was titrated over a threefold range. The proteins present in the various protein-DNA complexes are indicated to the left of the panels. (C) EMSA performed with the probes and proteins indicated [-, absence of (1-90)RcRd and RcRd proteins] above the lanes. The proteins present in the protein-DNA complex are indicated to the left.
|
Since the prominent complex observed with TBP and the (1-90)RcRd fusion protein did not depend on a intact PSE, we wondered whether it indeed contained both TBP and the SNAP190-derived fusion proteins. As shown in Fig. 4, ( 1-90)RcRd and TBP each bound poorly to the probe alone, as did GST fusion derivatives of each protein [G(1-90)RcRd and GTBP, lanes 2 to 5]. When (1-90)RcRd was combined with TBP, however, a protein-DNA complex was observed, as before (lane 6). The complex migrated with increasingly slower mobility upon replacement of (i) (1-90)RcRd with the larger protein G(1-90)RcRd (lane 7), (ii) TBP with the larger protein GTBP (lane 8), and (iii) both (1-90)RcRd and TBP with the larger GST fusion proteins (lane 9). It is not clear why fusion of the GST moiety to the (1-90)RcRd protein affected migration of the complex less than fusion of the GST moiety to TBP (lanes 7 and 8). Nevertheless, the observation that fusion of the GST moiety to either protein does retard migration of the complex confirms that the complex does indeed contain both components. Together, these results suggest that a fusion protein consisting of the first 90 aa of SNAP190 and the RcRd DNA binding domain is capable of recruiting TBP to the DNA. The observation that this recruitment is not dependent on an intact PSE suggests that the (1-90)RcRd and RcRd(1-90) proteins bind with low specificity to DNA.
![]() View larger version (62K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 4. The complex observed in the presence of TBP and the (1-90)RcRd-HT fusion protein contains both TBP and (1-90)RcRd-HT. EMSA performed with the proteins indicated above the lanes and a probe containing the wild-type mouse U6 PSE and the human U6 TATA box. G(1-90)RcRd and GTBP are GST fusion proteins. The proteins present in each protein-DNA complex are indicated to the right. In lane 1 no proteins were added to the probe.
|
The stmSNAPcs are competent for U6 transcription. We depleted a transcription extract of endogenous SNAPc with a mixture of anti-SNAP190 and anti-SNAP43 antibodies and tested the abilities of the various stmSNAPcs to restore transcription in the depleted extract. As shown in Fig. 6, addition of TBP to the untreated extract stimulated transcription, indicating that TBP was limiting (lane 2). Upon treatment of the extract with preimmune antibody beads, transcription was diminished but less so than upon depletion with anti-SNAP190 and anti-SNAP43 beads (compare lanes 3 and 5). Upon addition of TBP, transcription from the extract treated with preimmune beads was restored to near-wild-type levels, whereas transcription from the extract depleted with anti-SNAP190 and anti-SNAP43 beads was stimulated only slightly (compare lanes 4 and 6). To test the stmSNAPcs, we complemented the depleted extract with a constant amount of TBP and increasing amounts of the various stmSNAPcs. The amounts of the various stmSNAPcs were normalized as in Fig. 2B to give rise to equal binding to the mouse U6 PSE. As shown in Fig. 6, lanes 7 to 18, the various stmSNAPcs restored transcription to different levels, but there was no correlation between the ability of an stmSNAPc to restore transcription and its ability to recruit TBP. Thus, stmSNAPc#7, stmSNAPc#8, stmSNAPc#23, and stmSNAPc#24, which cannot recruit TBP efficiently (Fig. 2), were as active or more active than stmSNAPc#1 and stmSNAPc#2, which recruit TBP efficiently. Addition of the (1-90)RcRd protein did not stimulate transcription above the levels observed with addition of just TBP, indicating that this protein is inactive for transcription (compare lanes 19 and 20 to lane 6). Together, these results indicate that the ability of the stmSNAPcs to recruit TBP to the TATA box is not essential for transcription. Further, they show that stmSNAPc#8, which contains SNAP190 aa 84 to 505, SNAP43 aa 1 to 268, and SNAP50, contains all the information required to direct basal levels of RNA polymerase III transcription. On the other hand, the (1-90)RcRd SNAP190 derivative on its own is not capable of directing transcription, indicating that it is lacking essential parts present in stmSNAPc#8.
![]() View larger version (59K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 6. The transcription activities of different stmSNAPcs does not correlate with their abilities to recruit TBP. A whole-cell extract was either left untreated (lanes 1 and 2) or treated with preimmune (PRE-IMM.) antibody beads (lanes 3 and 4) or with a mixture of anti-SNAP190 ( -SNAP190) and anti-SNAP43 ( -SNAP43) antibody beads (lanes 5 to 20). The extracts were then complemented with the proteins indicated above the lanes. The presence (+) or absence (-) of TBP and the amount of the stmSNAPc protein (indicated by the height of the triangle) are indicated over the lanes. The extracts were programmed with the plasmid pU6/Hae/RA.2, which carries the human U6 promoter. The titrations of the stmSNAPcs and the (1-90)RcRd protein were over a threefold range. The transcripts were analyzed by RNase T1 protection. The signals corresponding to correctly initiated U6 RNA (U6) or to a control RNA (IC) included in the reaction mixtures to monitor RNA handling and recovery are indicated to the left of the gel.
|
![]() View larger version (60K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 7. TBP can be recruited to the U6 transcription initiation complex in the absence of SNAP190 aa 1 to 83. EMSA performed with the proteins indicated above the lanes and a probe containing the wild-type mouse U6 PSE and the human U6 TATA box. The amounts (indicated by the height of the triangle) of an anti-SNAP190 antibody ( -190) (CS696) and G-TBP, a GST-TBP fusion protein, are indicated over the lanes.The symbols to the right of different protein-DNA complexes indicate complexes containing proteins as follows: white circles, TBP and Brf2; blue circles, G-TBP and Brf2; white triangles, stmSNAPc#1 and TBP; blue triangles, stmSNAPc#1 and G-TBP; red triangle, stmSNAPc#1, TBP, and anti-SNAP190; white diamonds, stmSNAPc#1, TBP, and Brf2; blue diamonds, stmSNAPc#1, G-TBP, and Brf2; red diamonds, stmSNAPc#1, TBP, Brf2, and anti-SNAP190. (B) EMSA performed with probes containing the wild-type mouse U6 PSE and either a wild-type or mutant human U6 TATA box as indicated above the lanes, and the proteins indicated above the lanes. The Brf2 titrations were over a threefold range. The symbols at the right of different protein-DNA complexes indicate complexes containing proteins as follows: white circles, TBP and Brf2; white triangles, stmSNAPc#1 and TBP; white diamonds, stmSNAPc#1 or stmSNAPc#8, TBP, and Brf2.
|
When Brf2 was added to the stmSNAPc#1-TBP complex, a new complex of lower mobility was obtained (Fig. 7A, lane 13, white diamond). The mobility of this complex was retarded by increasing amounts of anti-SNAP190 antibody (lanes 14 and 15, red diamond) and by replacement of TBP with the larger GST-TBP fusion protein (lanes 18 and 19, blue diamond), consistent with it containing stmSNAPc#1 and TBP. Moreover, complexes formed in the presence of Brf2 consistently migrated slightly more slowly than the corresponding complexes lacking Brf2, confirming that these complexes indeed contain Brf2 [compare (i) the stmSNAPc#1-TBP-Brf2 complex in lane 13 (white diamond) with the stmSNAPc#1-TBP complex in lane 12 (white triangle); (ii) the stmSNAPc#1-TBP-Brf2-
-190 complex in lanes 14 and 15 (red diamond) to the stmSNAPc#1-TBP-
-190 complex in lane 8 (red triangle); (iii) the stmSNAPc#1-G-TBP-Brf2 complex in lanes 18 and 19 (blue diamond) to the stmSNAPc#1-G-TBP complex in lane 16 (blue triangle)]. Together, these results indicate that TBP binds cooperatively not only with stmSNAPc#1 but also with Brf2. Further, a complex containing all three components is efficiently obtained.
We next compared stmSNAPc#1, which can recruit TBP, with stmSNAPc#8, which is deficient in TBP recruitment, for assembly into complexes containing TBP and Brf2. As shown in Fig. 7B, neither TBP nor Brf2 bound efficiently to DNA on their own, but together, they formed a strong complex, as before (lane 4, white circle). Both stmSNAPc#1 and stmSNAPc#8 bound efficiently to the mouse U6 PSE (lanes 5 and 11) but only stmSNAPc#1 recruited TBP to the DNA (compare lanes 6 and 12, white triangle). Furthermore, we did not observe cooperative binding of Brf2 and any of the two stmSNAPcs (lanes 10 and 16). Upon addition of increasing amounts of Brf2, increasing amounts of the stmSNAPc#1-TBP-Brf2 complex were obtained (lanes 7 to 9, white diamond). Remarkably, addition of Brf2 to the binding reaction mixture containing stmSNAPc#8 and TBP also resulted in efficient formation of a complex containing the three components, indicating that TBP can be recruited through Brf2 (lanes 13 to 15, white diamond). In addition, a complex containing just TBP and Brf2 was observed in the presence of both stmSNAPcs (for example, lane 15, white circle), although with stmSNAPc#1 the complex was difficult to visualize because it comigrated with the complex that probably corresponds to an altered conformation of stmSNAPc#1 (compare lane 9, white circle, with the binding reaction mixture lacking Brf2 in lane 6). All the complexes containing TBP and Brf2 were dependent on the presence of a TATA box in the probe (lanes 18 to 28).
|
|
|---|
|
View larger version (5K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 8. Known functional regions of SNAP190. The known functional regions of SNAP190 follow: SNAP190 aa 34 to 83, TBP recruitment region 1 (TRR1); SNAP190 aa 84 to138, SNAP19- and SNAP43-interacting region; SNAP190 aa 263 to 503, Myb domain; SNAP190 aa 869 to 912, Oct-1-interacting region (OIR); and SNAP190 aa 1281 to 1393, SNAP45-interacting region.
|
It will be very interesting to determine whether SNAPcs that still contain the damper of DNA binding but are unable to bind cooperatively with TBP are inactive for transcription from the core U6 promoter lacking the Oct-1 binding site. We do not know, however, whether deletion of the SNAP190 TRR1 will be sufficient to debilitate recruitment of TBP by the full-length SNAPc. Indeed, although this region is required for efficient TBP recruitment in the context of stmSNAPc#1 (and is sufficient to recruit TBP when fused to the RcRd repeats), it is quite possible that the full-length complex contains other regions, either in the C-terminal two thirds of SNAP190 or in SNAP45 or in SNAP19, that act redundantly with the SNAP190 TRR1 region.
The smallest stmSNAPc we tested in transcription is stmSNAPc#8, which lacks the last 100 aa of SNAP43 as well as the first 83 aa and the last 9 aa of the SNAP190 truncation present in mini-SNAPc. Remarkably, this complex is active for basal RNA polymerase III transcription from the human U6 promoter, indicating that it contains all the information required to recruit, ultimately, RNA polymerase III. We do not know whether RNA polymerase III directly contacts SNAPc, but our results suggest that any essential contact would involve subunits or part of subunits present in stmSNAPc#8, the smallest functional SNAPc subcomplex we have assembled so far.
This work was funded in part by NIH grant GM38810. N.H. and B.M. are supported by the Howard Hughes Medical Institute.
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»