Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Molecular and Cellular Biology, December 2002, p. 8254-8266, Vol. 22, No. 23
0270-7306/02/$04.00+0 DOI: 10.1128/MCB.22.23.8254-8266.2002
Copyright © 2002, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, Centre de Genetique Moleculaire, 91190 Gif-sur-Yvette, France,1 Department of Biology, Howard Hughes Medical Institute, Brandeis University, Waltham, Massachusetts 02454,2 Department of Molecular Biology, Aarhus University, 8000 Aarhus C., Denmark3
Received 11 July 2002/ Returned for modification 23 July 2002/ Accepted 4 September 2002
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
Only a small fraction of S. cerevisiae transcripts contain introns, making pre-mRNA splicing insufficient to link the general mRNA population to nuclear export. Instead, 3'-end formation seems to play a major role in this organism. In temperature-sensitive (ts) mutants of the 3'-end processing factors rna14, rna15, and poly(A) polymerase (pap1), mRNA nuclear export is blocked (4, 16). Furthermore, uncapped T7 polymerase-directed transcripts are efficient substrates for nuclear export only if they are cleaved and polyadenylated, whereas unadenylated transcripts terminated due to a T7 terminator sequence are sequestered within the nucleus (11). These results indicate that, in contrast to the 5'-end cap, a proper 3' end is required for nuclear export.
We recently discovered that a block to nuclear export leads to rapid and dramatic effects on the polyadenylation and subnuclear localization of two heat shock mRNAs, SSA4 and HSP104 (19). In a number of export mutants, these transcripts were sequestered at or near their sites of transcription and the mRNAs had poly(A) tails approximately twice as long as those found in a wild-type strain. Interestingly, transcripts synthesized without a poly(A) tail in the pap1-1 mutant were also retained in transcription site foci. This retention required Rrp6p as well as other components of the nuclear exosome, which is a large complex of exonucleolytic enzymes; i.e., in exosome mutants, unadenylated as well as hyperadenylated mRNAs are released from transcription sites and proceed in their metabolism (16). Although the molecular basis for exosome-mediated transcription site retention is not understood, these observations suggest that events closely linked to transcription play important roles in defining an export-competent mRNA. As a consequence, it is highly likely that early mRNA export factors will be found associated with sites of active transcription. Indeed, chromatin immunoprecipitation assays have shown that the RNA binding proteins Yra1p and Npl3p associate with mRNA while it is still in close proximity to chromatin (26). Sub2p/UAP56 is also thought to act at an early step in mRNA metabolism. Yeast SUB2 interacts genetically with YRA1, and the products of the two genes interact physically (38). Furthermore, mutations of SUB2 lead to a general defect in mRNA export and cause Rrp6p-dependent stalling of SSA4 and HSP104 RNAs at or near transcription sites (18, 38). It has recently been shown that both Yra1p and Sub2p are associated with the heterotetrameric THO-protein complex, which is genetically and physically linked to the transcription machinery (7, 8, 39). This observation suggested a role for members of the THO complex in mRNA export, which has indeed previously been determined to exist (39). Although the mechanistic rationale underlying these transport defects at the molecular level is presently unclear, they could be due to inefficient loading of export factor(s) onto the nascent transcript. Alternatively, the lesion could be indirect: for example, through more subtle effects on 3'-end formation.
Inspired by evidence linking SUB2 genetically and physically to HPR1 (17, 35), we have analyzed the status of nascent HSP104 transcripts in sub2 and hpr1 mutant strains as well as in strains with deletions of other components of the Hpr1p-containing THO-protein complex (8, 9). We find that a substantial pool of nuclear HSP104 RNA is 3'-end truncated in these mutants. Moreover, a share of transcripts are rapidly sequestered at or near transcription sites. Deletion of the RRP6 exonuclease restores a quasinormal level of full-length transcripts and reverses the transcript sequestration phenotype. This indicates that HSP104 transcripts produced in these mutants are subject to detection and partial degradation by Rrp6p. We have also analyzed transcripts produced in RNA 3'-end cleavage mutants as well as transcripts terminated by a self-cleaving ribozyme. In both cases, transcripts are retained within transcription site foci. All of the results show that several classes of defective RNPs are subject to a quality control step at or near the site of transcription.
|
|
|---|
rrp6 and rat7-1/
rrp6. All other strains used are derived from W303 or have been backcrossed to W303 multiple times. Double mutants were created by standard genetic crosses. Original strains were kindly provided by H. Klein (
hpr1), A. Aguilera (
mft1 and
tho2), and P. Thuriaux (
gcn5,
ppr2, and
rbp9). rna14-3, rna15-2, and
xrn1 strains were a gift from F. Lacroute and M. Minet. |
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. S. cerevisiae strains used in this study
|
Culture growth, RNA isolation, and in vivo protein labeling.
For experiments involving temperature shifts, yeast cultures were grown in yeast extract-peptone-dextrose medium at 25°C. Temperature shifts were performed by mixing a relevant volume of 25°C culture with an equal volume of 49°C medium, after which incubation was continued at 37°C for the specified times. For experiments involving GFP RNA expression, W303 wild-type cells transformed with pRS304-2µm-polII-GFP-RZ or pRS304-2µm-polII-GFP and
rrp6 cells transformed with pRS304-2µm-polII-GFP-RZ were grown at 30°C in tryptophan dropout medium to an optical density at 600 nm of 0.3. For isolation of total RNA, cells were generally collected by centrifugation, washed once with ice-cold H2O, and stored at -80°C. Total RNA was extracted using the hot acid phenol method (1).
RNA analysis. For Northern blot analysis of HSP104 RNA, 20 µg of total RNA was used. In DNA oligonucleotide-RNase H digestion reactions, DNA oligonucleotide DL163 (5'-ACATTTTCATCACGAGATTTACCC, directed against nucleotides [nt] 2583 to 2606 of HSP104 RNA) and DNA oligonucleotide DL195 (5'-TGAAGGCAGCTAGAATATGTATAGG, directed against nt 94 to 118 of HSP104 RNA) were used in experiments measuring levels of 3' and 5' ends, respectively. To facilitate quantitation of the 3' ends, an oligo(dT)18 oligonucleotide was included for these RNase H reactions. To detect signals from the HSP104 5' and 3' ends, membranes were probed sequentially with radiolabeled oligonucleotides DL190 (5'-TTGAGCCAACGTCAAAATCGTTAGAGCCCTTTCTGTAAATTGCGTTTGGTCGTTCAT, directed against nt 1 to 57 of HSP104 RNA) and DL164 (5'-TTATCGTCATCACCTAACGTGTCAGCCCCTATAGTAGCTTCGTGATTTGGTAGAACTTCC, directed against nt 2631 to 2690 of HSP104 RNA), respectively. Radioactive signals of individual samples were quantitated on a PhosphorImager and normalized to the amount of U4 RNA. The integrity of HSP104 RNA in mutant strains, at a given time after temperature shift, was calculated as the level of HSP104 RNA 5' or 3' end in the mutant relative to the wild-type strain. RNA was resolved by using 6% denaturing polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis.
RNAs that failed to terminate correctly in the rna14-3 and rna14-3/
rrp6 strains were analyzed using RNase H and oligonucleotides D1 and D2 directed against sequences 221 and 300 nt downstream of the stop codon, respectively.
For Northern blot analysis of GFP RNAs, 2 µg of total RNA was cleaved with RNase H by using oligonucleotide KD290 (5'-GAA CGC TTC CAT CTT CAA TGT TGT) and, where applicable, oligo(dT)18. Oligonucleotide KD290 is complementary to the GFP ORF,
200 nt upstream of the stop codon. Membranes were probed with radiolabeled oligonucleotide KD282 (5'-GCA GCC AGA TCC TTT GTA TAG TTC ATC CAT GCC ATG) and washed in 2x SSC (1x SSC is 0.15 M NaCl plus 0.015 M sodium citrate)-0.1% sodium dodecyl sulfate for 15 min, twice at 25°C and twice at 42°C. Bands were visualized by autoradiography.
FISH analysis. Fixation and preparation of cells for fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) analysis were done as previously described (19). Detection of HSP104 mRNA was done using Cy3-labeled THJ203, THJ204, THJ205, and THJ206 probes (19), poly(A)+ RNA was localized using a Cy3-labeled oligo(dT)70 probe, and GFP RNA was localized using CY3-labeled KD209, KD210, KD211, and KD212 probes, as described previously (11).
|
|
|---|
hpr1 mutation (reference 41 and data not shown).
![]() View larger version (64K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. The sub2-201 mutation is synthetically lethal with deletion of any one of the HPR1, THO2, and MFT1 genes of the THO complex. sub2, sub2/ hpr1, sub2/ tho2, and sub2/ mft1 cells, expressing Sub2-201p from a TRP1-marked plasmid and Sub2p from a URA3-marked plasmid, were grown at 24°C on medium containing 5-FOA (to rid the cells of Sub2p) or on URA dropout plates (CSM-URA), as indicated.
|
tho2 and sub2-201/
mft1 double mutants. As shown in Fig. 1, neither double mutant was viable. This result is consistent with that of a recent report from the Hurt laboratory of work performed with the sub2-85 mutant allele (39).
HSP104 transcripts are sequestered in Rrp6p-dependent transcription site foci in strains from which individual THO components are deleted.
Thermosensitive mutants of Sub2p show nuclear accumulation of mRNA at the restrictive temperature (18, 38). Because of the genetic and physical association between SUB2 and HPR1, we analyzed the fate of transcripts produced in an hpr1 null environment. The
hpr1 mutant was shifted to 37°C, and HSP104 RNA localization was assayed by FISH analysis utilizing sequence-specific probes. Under these experimental conditions, heat shock gene expression is transiently induced and HSP104 expression follows a pseudo-pulse-chase profile. At the 15-min time point, a single nuclear dot appeared in the majority of the cells (Fig. 2A, second row), which was a result identical to that previously observed with a number of ts mutant strains that inhibit mRNA export (16, 18, 19). The dot reflects retention of the transcript at or near its site of transcription (reference 19 and data not shown). However, this nuclear sequestration phenotype was more transient than previously observed for other mRNA export mutants; i.e., the HSP104 dot disappeared after a 60-min incubation at 37°C (Fig. 2A, third row). Since HSP104 RNA levels, as measured by Northern blotting, do not decrease over time (Fig. 3A), this result indicates an incomplete block to transcription site release, leading to the disappearance of the HSP104 RNA in situ signal after the transcriptional shutoff. The mRNA nuclear export phenotype of the
hpr1 strain was also evident when poly(A)+ RNA localization was assayed using an oligo(dT) in situ probe (Fig. 2A, right panel).
![]() View larger version (53K): [in a new window] |
FIG.2. Deletion of HPR1 or MFT1 leads to Rrp6p-dependent transcription site focus accumulation of HSP104 RNA. (A) HSP104 and poly(A)+ RNA FISH analysis of hpr1 cultures grown at 25°C or temperature shifted to 37°C for 15 or 60 min and HSP104 RNA FISH analysis of hpr1/ rrp6 cultures temperature shifted to 37°C for 15 min, as indicated. (B) RNA FISH analysis of mft1 and mft1/ rrp6 cultures, as described for panel A. For the hpr1/ rrp6 strain, HSP104 RNA FISH analysis was also performed on a culture grown for 60 min at 37°C. DNA was stained with DAPI (4',6'-diamidino-2-phenylindole).
|
![]() ![]() View larger version (113K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. Rrp6p-dependent generation of 3'-end-truncated transcripts in hpr1, sub2-201, and mft1 mutant backgrounds. (A) Northern analysis of HSP104 RNA (or U4 snRNA as a control) isolated from W303, hpr1, and hpr1/ rrp6 cultures harvested at the indicated time points after a 37°C temperature shift. Prior to gel electrophoresis, all samples were treated with RNase H and the DL163 oligonucleotide complementary to nt 2583 to 2606 of the HSP104 gene. The row above the upper gel (dT) indicates whether the RNA sample was also treated with oligo(dT) to remove the poly(A) tail. HSP104 RNA was visualized using a radiolabeled DNA oligonucleotide (DL164) complementary to nt 2631 to 2690 of the HSP104 gene. (B) Schematic representation of the HSP104 RNA, indicating positions cleaved by RNase H and the DNA oligonucleotides DL195, DL163, and oligo(dT). Positions recognized by the HSP104 RNA FISH probes (THJ203 to THJ206) are also shown. (C) Top row, Northern analysis of HSP104 RNA isolated from W303, hpr1, and hpr1/ rrp6; middle row, Northern analysis of HSP104 RNA isolated from W303, sub2-201, and sub2-201/ rrp6; bottom row, Northern analysis of HSP104 RNA isolated from W303, mft1, and mft1/ rrp6. All cultures were harvested at the indicated time points after a 37°C temperature shift. To measure 5'-end levels, oligonucleotide DL195 complementary to nt 94 to 118 of the HSP104 gene was used in the RNase H cleavage reaction and a radiolabeled DNA oligonucleotide spanning the first 57 nt of HSP104 was used for hybridization. HSP104 3'-end abundance was measured as described for panel A. All samples were treated with oligo(dT) in the RNase H reaction to facilitate quantitation analysis. To quantitate relative HSP104 5'- and 3'-end levels, signals were normalized to the amount of U4 RNA and expressed in comparison to the percentage of RNA produced in a wild-type strain (set to a value of 100) at the same time point.
|
hpr1 strain resulted in almost the full disappearance of the HSP104 RNA nuclear dot at the 15-min time point. Instead, a diffuse HSP104 signal could be detected, which in some cells showed a mild nuclear accumulation (Fig. 2A, lower row). Disappearance of the nuclear dot is not due to lack of HSP104 RNA, since transcript levels were actually increased in the
hpr1/
rrp6 double-mutant strain compared to the
hpr1 single-mutant strain (Fig. 3A). Furthermore, deletion of cytoplasmic degradation components (i.e., XRN1 or SKI2) did not result in dot relief in the
hpr1 context (data not shown). Finally, Hsp104p protein synthesis was diminished in the
hpr1 strain after 15 min compared to a wild-type strain and normal levels were restored in the
hpr1/
rrp6 double-mutant strain (data not shown). We conclude that Rrp6p, and possibly the nuclear exosome, are involved in HSP104 RNA transcription site retention in the
hpr1 strain.
We next wanted to evaluate the involvement of other components of the THO complex in nuclear mRNA export and their relationships with RRP6. To this end, we analyzed the status of HSP104 transcripts in strains from which the inessential THO complex components MFT1 and THO2 (kindly provided by A. Aguilera) were deleted. As in
hpr1 cells, in
mft1 HSP104 RNA localized to a nuclear dot after a 15-min incubation at 37°C (Fig. 2B, second row). The signal intensity decreased slightly over time, although not as much as in the
hpr1 strain (compare Fig. 2A and B). Under similar conditions, nuclear accumulation of poly(A)+ RNA was also detectable in this strain (Fig. 2B, right panel). Similar results were obtained for the
tho2 strain (data not shown).
The contribution of Rrp6p to transcription site retention was evaluated by constructing a
mft1/
rrp6 strain (a
tho2/
rrp6 strain was not viable; see below). HSP104 RNA localization in
mft1/
rrp6 resembled that in
hpr1/
rrp6 (Fig. 2B, fourth and fifth rows). Northern blot analysis confirmed the presence of HSP104 RNA in the
mft1/
rrp6 strain (data not shown).
What is the nature of the transcription site-sequestered HSP104 transcripts in these strains? HSP104 RNA was detected with FISH probes directed towards the 3' end of the ORF (Fig. 3B). When we utilized a single probe (THJ203) that hybridizes to a HSP104 region immediately upstream of the stop codon, nuclear dots could also be detected (data not shown). We conclude that HSP104 transcripts with sequences at or very close to the stop codon are retained in transcription site foci.
Rrp6p-mediated degradation of HSP104 transcripts in the
hpr1,
mft1, and sub2-201 mutant strains.
Using our transcriptional pseudo-pulse-chase heat shock assay, we analyzed HSP104 transcripts biochemically by Northern blotting. In wild-type cells, HSP104 transcription is transiently induced at 37°C and a polyadenylated species first appears that is exported from the nucleus, deadenylated, and degraded in the cytoplasm (a representative gel is shown in Fig. 3A). In contrast, HSP104 RNA expressed in hpr1 null cells did not seem to proceed in its metabolism but accumulated with slightly longer poly(A) tails (Fig. 3A; compare lanes 1 to 4 with lanes 5 to 8). The overall amount of HSP104 RNA was increased in the
hpr1/
rrp6 double mutant compared to the
hpr1 single mutant (Fig. 3A; compare lanes 15 and 16 with lanes 17 and 18; see below for quantitation). Removal of HSP104 RNA poly(A) tails by oligo(dT) and RNase H revealed that the clear majority of transcripts had been polyadenylated.
Members of the THO complex have previously been implicated in transcription elongation (10). To determine Hpr1p, Mft1p, and Sub2p contributions to HSP104 RNA quality, we analyzed the status of HSP104 RNA 5' ends and 3' ends in W303,
hpr1,
mft1, and sub2-201 cells. Total RNA, harvested after a temperature shift, was subjected to oligonucleotide-directed RNase H cleavage and subsequent Northern analysis. Use of specific cleaving oligonucleotides and hybridization probes allowed independent assessment of 5'- and 3'-end abundance (Fig. 3B). In the
hpr1 and sub2-201 background, the amount of 3'-end fragments derived from the HSP104 RNA was significantly reduced at the 5- and 30-min time points (to approximately 20% of wild-type levels) (Fig. 3C [see right panels for quantitation]). On the other hand, the 5' ends were much less affected, which indicates the existence of 3'-end-truncated HSP104 transcripts in these two mutant strains. The presence of incomplete transcripts was even more pronounced in the
mft1 strain, with the 3' ends almost undetectable at the 5- and 15-min time points (Fig. 3C, lower part).
Given the proposed role for the THO protein complex, incomplete RNAs could be due to defective transcriptional elongation. However, deletion of the RRP6 gene from the
hpr1, sub2-201, and
mft1 backgrounds resulted in the almost complete restoration of HSP104 3'-end levels relative to HSP104 5'-end levels (Fig. 3C). This was not due to a general Rrp6p-mediated increase in mRNA abundance, since the levels of HSP104 3' ends (and 5' ends) were unaffected in rrp6 null cells compared to those of a wild-type strain (data not shown).
mRNA degradation in the cytoplasm occurs by two principal mechanisms: a major cap-dependent 5'-3' pathway and a minor cap-independent 3'-5' pathway (6). The exonuclease Xrn1p and the helicase Ski2p are nonessential, cytoplasmic factors involved in the 5'-3' and 3'-5' degradation pathways, respectively. Deletion of XRN1 (and to a minor extent, SKI2) in a wild-type strain resulted in stabilization of HSP104 RNA at the 30-min time point, as would be expected when cytoplasmic degradation of mRNA is inhibited (data not shown). However, deletion of XRN1 or SKI2 in a sub2-201 or
hpr1 background did not result in general HSP104 RNA stabilization or restoration of a proper 5'-end:3'-end ratio, in contrast to what was observed in the
hpr1/
rrp6 and sub2-201/
rrp6 double-mutant strains (data not shown). This strongly indicates that significant proportions of RNAs produced in
hpr1, sub2-201, and
mft1 environments are specifically degraded in the nucleus and suggests that Rrp6, and possibly the nuclear exosome, plays a major role in this process.
Specific genetic interactions between the THO complex and components of the nuclear exosome.
Rrp6p modulation of HSP104 localization and 3'-end abundance suggests a functional relationship between the THO protein complex and the nuclear exosome. Indeed,
hpr1/
rrp6 and
mft1/
rrp6 double-mutant strains are severely growth impaired at 24 and 30°C and inviable at all temperatures above 30°C (Table 2). Furthermore, a
tho2/
rrp6 strain is inviable at all temperatures tested (data not shown). We have previously reported an interaction between the sub2-201 mutation and deletion of RRP6 (18), and this observation extends to mutant YRA1 alleles, which are growth impaired or lethal in combination with exosome component mutations (41). Thus, SUB2, YRA1, HPR1, MFT1, and THO2 all show a genetic interaction with RRP6. Growth impairment of the sub2-201/
rrp6 and
hpr1/
rrp6 mutants could be linked to general aspects of mRNA degradation. However, deletion of SKI2 or XRN1 does not affect growth of the sub2-201 mutant at any temperature. Similarly,
hpr1/
xrn1 and
hpr1/
ski2 double-mutant strains show growth rates identical to that of a
hpr1 single mutant (Table 2). Thus, the link between HPR1 and SUB2 on the one hand and the RNA degradation machinery on the other appears to be restricted to the nucleus.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 2. Temperature sensitivity of strains
|
rrp6 or mtr2-26/
rrp6) grew slower than their single-mutant counterparts (Table 2). This genetic interaction pattern might reflect the fact that Yra1p, Sub2p, and the THO protein complex function at early transcription-associated steps in mRNA export, whereas the roles of Rat7p and Mtr2p are linked to later steps associated with nuclear pore complexes. We also tested for a genetic interaction between RRP6 and bona fide transcription elongation factors. As shown in Table 2, growth of cells from strains with a deletion of the PPR2 gene (transcription elongation factor TFIIS), RPB9 (RNA polII component), or GCN5 (SAGA- and ADA-complex-associated histone acetyltransferase) was unaffected by deletion of the RRP6 gene. Together, the genetic results strongly suggest that the interaction of THO complex components and the SUB2 helicase with RRP6 is related to a function that is specific for this set of proteins.
Read-through transcripts are retained and partially degraded in an Rrp6p-dependent manner.
It has been suggested that nonadenylated, 3'-OH ends trigger the degradation activity of Rrp6p (5). Data shown in the previous sections show that HSP104 RNA produced in sub2- or THO complex-defective mutants are retained and degraded in the nucleus. It is not entirely clear whether these transcripts are adenylated (see Discussion). With polyadenylation and free 3'-OH ends in mind, we turned to the 3'-end cleavage and transcription termination mutants rna14-3 and rna15-2 (31). As shown in Fig. 4A, HSP104 transcripts accumulate in an intranuclear dot at the nonpermissive temperature in these strains. Deletion of RRP6 significantly reduces this signal in both mutant backgrounds, despite a general increase in HSP104 RNA levels (Fig. 4B to E). A fraction of the HSP104 transcripts produced in the rna14-3 and rna15-2 strains appear much longer and heterogeneous than in a wild-type strain, which results in a diffuse Northern blot signal (Fig. 4B [also Fig. 4C; compare lanes 1 and 4] and data not shown). These longer transcripts derive from defective 3'-end cleavage and/or transcriptional termination in these strains, as read-through HSP104 transcripts can be cleaved by RNase H and DNA oligonucleotides D1 and D2, positioned downstream of the canonical poly(A) addition site (Fig. 4C and data not shown). HSP104 transcripts polyadenylated at the correct site could also be detected (Fig. 4C to D). Both read-through and correctly polyadenylated transcripts appear to be substrates for Rrp6p, since the amount of both species increases approximately threefold at the 15-min time point in the rna14-3/
rrp6 double mutant compared to the rna14-3 single mutant (Fig. 4D and E).
![]() View larger version (56K): [in a new window] |
FIG.4. HSP104 transcripts harboring extended 3' untranslated regions accumulate in Rrp6p-dependent transcription site foci. (A) HSP104 mRNA FISH analysis of rna14-3, rna14-3/ rrp6, rna15-2, and rna15-2/ rrp6 cultures temperature shifted to 37°C for 15 or 60 min. DNAs were stained with DAPI. (B) Northern analysis of HSP104 mRNA (or U4 snRNA as a control) isolated from rna14-3 and rna14-3/ rrp6 cultures harvested at the indicated time points after a 37°C temperature shift. Prior to gel electrophoresis, samples were treated with the DL163 oligonucleotide complementary to nt 2583 to 2606 of the HSP104 gene and RNase H. Approximate size markers are indicated. (C) Northern analysis of HSP104 RNA isolated from W303 and rna14-3/ rrp6 cultures 15 min after a 37°C temperature shift. Prior to gel electrophoresis, samples were treated with RNase H and the indicated oligonucleotide [none (-), oligo(dT), D1, or D2] complementary to the region of the HSP104 gene (as schematized above the gel) for read-through as well as polyadenylated transcripts. Migration of bands corresponding to oligo(dT), D1, and D2 cleavage is shown. (D) Northern analysis of read-through as well as polyadenylated HSP104 RNA content in rna14-3 and rna14-3/ rrp6 strains at 15- and 30-min time points after a 37°C temperature shift. To facilitate concomitant detection of read-through and polyadenylated HSP104 RNA, samples were treated with RNase H and a mix of oligonucleotide D1 and oligo(dT) prior to gel electrophoresis. (E) Quantitation of the result described for panel D. Signals were normalized to the amount of U4 RNA and expressed in comparison to the percentage of RNA produced in the rna14-3/ rrp6 strain (set to a value of 100) at the same time point.
|
Formation of free 3' ends in a wild-type strain results in transcription site retention.
To generate transcripts with free 3' ends without ts mutants and the consequent temperature change, we constructed a plasmid expressing a GFP RNA with a 3' end formed by a self-cleaving hammerhead ribozyme (33). The DNA was transformed into wild-type or
rrp6 cells, and the GFP RNA localization at 30°C was analyzed by using RNA FISH with probes specific for the GFP sequence. In wild-type cells, GFP RNA accumulated in nuclear granules, reminiscent of the signal obtained when transcription site-restricted transcripts are expressed from high-copy-number 2µm reporter plasmids (11, 19). The sequestration was dependent on the presence of Rrp6p, as the nuclear signal was significantly reduced in the
rrp6 strain (Fig. 5A, middle row). Furthermore, mRNA accumulation in nuclear granules was dependent on the ribozyme-produced 3' ends, as substitution of the hammerhead ribozyme sequence with a conventional yeast polyadenylation signal resulted in a GFP RNA signal dispersed throughout the cell (Fig. 5A, lower row). Northern analysis confirmed that the polyadenylation signal-containing construct produced RNAs with poly(A) tails of the expected length, whereas the ribozyme construct led to the synthesis of unadenylated transcripts (Fig. 5B). We conclude that Rrp6p is linked to the nuclear retention of transcripts with unadenylated 3' ends, regardless of their origin.
![]() View larger version (51K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 5. Transcripts whose 3' end is generated by a self-cleaving hammerhead ribozyme accumulate in Rrp6p-dependent transcription site foci. (A) GFP RNA FISH analysis of wild-type (top row) and rrp6 (middle row) strains transformed with a 2µm high-copy-number plasmid construct expressing GFP RNA terminated by a self-cleaving hammerhead ribozyme (polII-GFP-RZ) and wild-type cells transformed with a 2µm plasmid expressing GFP RNA terminated by a conventional 3'-end processing signal (polII-GFP) (bottom row). rrp6 cells were cotransformed with either a plasmid expressing the Rrp6p protein (top and bottom rows) or empty vector (middle row). Log-phase cultures growing at 30°C were fixed and subjected to RNA FISH utilizing probes specific for the GFP ORF. DNA was stained with DAPI. dT, oligo(dT). (B) Northern analysis of GFP RNA from the cultures described above. WT, wild type.
|
|
|
|---|
Data presented in this paper strengthen the functional interactions between export factors and members of the THO complex. Not only is the sub2-201 mutation synthetically lethal with deletion of the HPR1 gene, but a similar relationship also extends to the two other THO complex genes tested, THO2 and MFT1. Moreover, Sub2p interacts directly with Hpr1p and Yra1p, which indicates that the observed genetic interaction between SUB2, YRA1, and the THO complex is due to direct protein-protein interactions (39, 41).
Deletion of all tested members of the THO complex leads to sequestration of newly synthesized HSP104 transcripts in transcription site foci. This mRNA retention is Rrp6p dependent, which is a finding identical to the previously reported finding for inactivation of SUB2 (18). The exact nature of sequestered HSP104 transcripts in sub2 and THO complex mutants remains undetermined, as we cannot ascertain whether 3'-end-truncated transcripts are retained in transcription site foci or not. However, we note that HSP104 RNA is detectable with an in situ probe complementary to a sequence immediately upstream of the stop codon. Thus, complete, or nearly complete, transcripts are retained. Moreover, polyadenylated RNAs accumulate in the nucleus in THO complex mutants (39; this study). It is therefore likely that the HSP104 RNAs, which can be detected in a nuclear dot, belong to the class of transcripts that either have not yet been degraded (see below) or escaped degradation and await further processing steps (e.g., formation of export-competent mRNP).
Read-through HSP104 RNAs produced in rna14-3 and rna15-2 mutants are also retained in Rrp6p-dependent transcription site foci. These transcripts harbor extended 3' untranslated regions, which are presumably unadenylated. Furthermore, transcripts generated by a self-cleaving hammerhead ribozyme are also subject to transcription site retention by Rrp6p. All of our results show that detection by Rrp6p, and possibly by the nuclear exosome, controls the release of several different incompletely and/or improperly processed mRNAs. Although it is presently unclear how recognition by Rrp6p is achieved, our results with the self-cleaving ribozyme imply that recognition of aberrant mRNA can occur independently of a polyadenylation signal and thus without binding of all factors normally involved in 3'-end formation.
THO complex mutants were originally described as defective in transcription of the bacterial LacZ gene, as well as of long and/or GC-rich yeast ORFs (9, 10). In the present study, we observed 3'-end-truncated HSP104 transcripts in THO complex and sub2-201 mutants. However, deletion of RRP6 leads to almost complete restoration of full-length HSP104 transcripts. Consistent with our results, LacZ transcript levels are also restored in a yra1 mutant upon deletion of RRP6 (41). Although an inhibitory role of Rrp6p on transcriptional elongation cannot be excluded, the specific restoration of HSP104 3' ends (as opposed to an overall stabilization of HSP104 RNA) supports the hypothesis that incomplete HSP104 transcripts derive from partial degradation by Rrp6p. It is unclear why the exosome does not degrade HSP104 RNA to completion, but this might be due to inhibitory features of the substrate mRNP.
What is the substrate for Rrp6p? Oligo(dT)/RNase H digestion showed that the majority of restored HSP104 RNAs in double mutants are polyadenylated. Thus, either RNAs degraded in the presence of Rrp6p were originally polyadenylated, or RNAs produced in a THO-mutant environment can undergo normal polyadenylation only in the absence of competitive Rrp6p degradation. Consistent with these possibilities, we found that polyadenylated as well as read-through transcripts are stabilized when RRP6 is deleted in an rna14-3 mutant background (Fig. 4). This suggests that a nuclear degradation process might outcompete a defective mRNP formation step, in the THO and sub2 as well as the rna14-3 mutant backgrounds. Alternatively, polyadenylation took place in these mutants before degradation. Inefficiently spliced RNAs are also substrates of the nuclear exosome, and nuclear degradation has been shown to compete with inefficient splicing (3). Although these observations suggest that nuclear RNA degradation is a general and important way of controlling aberrant (and maybe even normal) transcript abundance, it is not known how this is controlled.
A distinctive feature of SUB2, YRA1, and THO complex genes is their strong genetic interaction with the nuclear exosome component RRP6. This appears to be specific, as deletion of cytoplasmic mRNA degradation factors XRN1 and SKI2 does not affect growth of
hpr1 or sub2-201 strains. Furthermore, growth of a RRP6 deletion strain is unaffected when combined with lesions in three other classes of genes involved in mRNA metabolism: (i) conventional mRNA export factors MTR2 and RAT7, (ii) 3'-end formation components RNA14, RNA15, and PAP1, and (iii) bona fide transcriptional elongation factors GCN5, PPR2, and RPB9. The latter result suggests that a transcriptional elongation failure per se is insufficient to explain the genetic interaction of the THO complex with the nuclear exosome. The synthetic growth defects between mutants of yra1, sub2, or the THO complex with mutations of the nuclear exosome might be due to transcription site release or to reduced degradation. However, mRNA release is not toxic in the context of tested polyadenylation, transcription termination, or mRNA export mutants. This suggests that the released mRNP in THO complex, sub2, and yra1 double mutants has a different composition and/or might improperly sequester an important subset of factors.
The hypothesis of involvement of the THO complex in transcription is based on the assessment of transcript abundance in mutants and on run-on experiments. In light of the results presented in this report, we suggest that transcript abundance in THO complex and sub2 mutants is at least partially dependent on the extent of nuclear degradation. This, in turn, is probably triggered by defects in late events in transcription, 3'-end processing, and/or mRNP formation. Chromatin immunoprecipitation experiments indeed suggest a role of the THO complex in mRNP formation and specifically in the recruitment of Sub2p and Yra1p to nascent RNA (39, 41). Interestingly, LacZ sequences affect transcript abundance in mutants more markedly when located at the 3' end of chimeric ORFs (10), which is consistent with the progressive cotranscriptional constitution of a functional mRNP. This hypothesis does not exclude functional feedback of mRNP formation on transcription elongation efficiency or pausing, possibly implicating factors recruited by the THO complex in one or more aspects of these processes. In this view, the primary effect of the THO complex is on nascent mRNP formation.
This work was supported by the Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (D.L.), the National Institutes of Health (M.R.), and the Danish Research Council and Novo Nordisk Foundation (T.H.J.).
|
|
|---|
5' exoribonucleases. Cell 91:457-466.[CrossRef][Medline]
is synthetically lethal with two conditional alleles of the acetyl coenzyme A carboxylase gene and causes a defect in nuclear export of polyadenylated RNA. Mol. Cell. Biol. 19:3415-3422.
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»