Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Molecular and Cellular Biology, December 2005, p. 10782-10790, Vol. 25, No. 24
0270-7306/05/$08.00+0 doi:10.1128/MCB.25.24.10782-10790.2005
Copyright © 2005, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
Department of Pathology, University of Michigan Medical School, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109-0602
Received 23 July 2005/ Returned for modification 18 August 2005/ Accepted 23 September 2005
|
|
|---|
-helix that is both required for its NHEJ function and strikingly similar to a DNA-dependent protein kinase interaction motif in human Ku80. These results identify a novel role in yeast NHEJ for the poorly characterized Ku80 C-terminal and Xrs2 FHA domains, and they suggest that redundant binding of DNA ligase IV facilitates completion of this DNA repair event. |
|
|---|
Proper formation of the MRX complex requires three proteins: Mre11, Rad50, and Xrs2 (Nbs1 in mammalian cells). Deletion of any gene results in severe NHEJ deficiency, mild recombination defects, shortened telomeres, and meiotic defects (7, 11). Mre11 harbors a nuclease domain and forms strong protein-protein interactions with Rad50 and Nbs1/Xrs2 (7). Rad50 is similar to structural maintenance of chromosome (SMC) proteins, with a split ABC ATPase domain whose parts are separated by a long coiled-coil region that homodimerizes via a zinc hook (19). Less is known about Nbs1/Xrs2, but it is proposed to harbor forkhead-associated (FHA) and BRCA1 C-terminal (BRCT) domains, which have been shown to mediate phosphopeptide-specific protein-protein interactions (7, 12). Although these domains are important in Nbs1 for binding to
-H2AX, there were no known binding partners for the corresponding domains of Xrs2 (22). How MRX participates in NHEJ is not well understood.
Like MRX, the Ku heterodimer has multiple cellular functions. In addition to NHEJ, it is required for protection of the telomeres from nucleolytic degradation, epigenetic silencing of genes positioned near telomeres (the telomere position effect [TPE]), and perinuclear anchoring of the telomeres (1, 2, 3, 31, 37). In higher eukaryotes, the Ku heterodimer associates with the DNA-PKcs protein to form the complete DNA-dependent protein kinase (DNA-PK), which is essential for NHEJ (29). The Ku subunits intertwine to form a ring that engages a DSB by sliding onto its end (42), positioning it to guide further events in the repair process.
Unlike those of MRX and Ku, the actions of the DNA ligase IV complex appear restricted to NHEJ. The DNA ligase IV complex consists of DNA ligase IV itself and XRCC4 (Dnl4 and Lif1 in yeast). Dnl4 binds strongly to Lif1, and both proteins are essential for NHEJ (39, 43). Nej1 modulates the NHEJ activity of this complex in yeast by interacting with the globular amino-terminal region of Lif1 (14).
While many studies have elucidated the molecular architecture of MRX, Ku, and DNA ligase IV independently, very little is known about how they interact to execute NHEJ. To systematically identify protein-protein interactions involved in NHEJ, we performed a comprehensive yeast two-hybrid screen on all known Saccharomyces cerevisiae NHEJ proteins and their individual domains. This analysis confirmed all known interactions and, importantly, suggested three additional interactions between specific regions of Dnl4-Yku80, Mre11-Yku80, and Xrs2-Lif1. These results guided mutational analysis of the C terminus of Yku80 and the FHA domain of Xrs2 which showed that these regions are redundantly and specifically required for NHEJ. This Yku80 C-terminal motif mapped to a putative amphipathic helix with intriguing similarities to Ku80 proteins from other species.
|
|
|---|
-inc ade2::HOSD(+1)::STE3-MET15 his3
1 leu2
met15
ura3
] has been described previously (9). The TPE strain YW1452 (MATa his3
1 leu2
met15
ura3
ppr1
::LEU2 yku80
::kanMX4 URA3-TPE) was derived from the yku80
strain from the genome deletion array (46). All strains were grown at 30°C (unless otherwise specified) in either a rich medium containing 1% yeast extract, 2% peptone, 2% dextrose, and 40 µg/ml adenine (YPAD) or a synthetic defined (SD) medium with either 2% glucose or galactose.
NHEJ yeast two-hybrid screen.
Yeast two-hybrid constructs were created by gap repair in yeast and tested for interaction by mating as described in the "Supplemental methods" section of the supplemental material. For confirmation, plasmids mediating novel interactions were isolated by electroporation into ElectroMAX DH10B competent cells (Invitrogen). Recovered plasmids were sequenced, and 12 of 12 plasmids tested demonstrated correct recombination, although 3 plasmids contained single-nucleotide changes presumably introduced by PCR. To confirm novel interactions in haploid strains, the corresponding bait and prey plasmids were cotransformed into PJ694-
. Two independent clones were then spotted onto plates lacking histidine or adenine. ß-Galactosidase activity was assayed as described elsewhere (34).
Prey expression constructs harboring yku80 point mutations were cloned by gap repair into PJ694-
using the oligonucleotide primers OW1646 (5'-CCA CCA AAC CCA AAA AAA GAG ATC GAA TTC CAG CTG GAA TGG ATT CAC CAA CTG) and OW1670 (5'-TCG ACG GAT CCC CGG GAA TTG CCA TGG TGG TCA ATT ATT GCT ATT GTT TGG ACT TCC) and genomic DNA containing the mutated sequence of interest. Strains were then transformed with the Dnl4(1-681) bait. These strains were grown for 2 days in SD medium lacking leucine and tryptophan and plated to nonselective plates and plates lacking histidine to determine the percentage of His+ cells.
Mutational analysis.
All yku80 mutations were constructed in the YKU80 chromosomal gene so that expression was driven from the native promoter. Creation of single and multiple amino acid substitutions involved PCR amplification of tandem DNA regions on either side of the mutation site that contained approximately 20 bp of overlap determined by the two internal PCR primers that encoded the desired mutation (sequences available upon request). These PCR products were then cotransformed into YW1404, a derivative of YW1276 in which the sequence encoding Yku80 amino acids 539 to 629 had been replaced with the URA3 marker. Three-way recombination between the PCR fragments and the endogenous locus results in replacement of the URA3 marker with the amino acid 539-to-629 sequence encoding specific amino acid changes. Three independent 5-fluoroorotic acid (5-FOA)-resistant isolates were subjected to suicide deletion analysis and growth at 37°C. YW1404 displays phenotypes equivalent to the yku80
strain; it is severely NHEJ defective and is sensitive to growth at 37°C. Transformants that retained temperature sensitivity thus corresponded to recombination failures and were disregarded. Most mutants were subsequently verified by sequencing. Truncations were created by introduction of a stop codon after residues 618, 604, 590, 576, and 551 in chromosomal YKU80.
xrs2
FHA was generated by targeted replacement of amino acids 1 to 125 with the URA3 marker in YW1276. In this allele, URA3 is coupled to the strong ADH1 promoter and a start codon, such that expression of xrs2
FHA is driven by the ADH1 promoter beginning at Xrs2 residue 126. As a control, we also generated an amino-terminal deletion of residues 2 to 125 under the control of the endogenous XRS2 promoter. This strain behaved similarly to xrs2
FHA (data not shown), and therefore we used the strain containing the URA3 marker in subsequent experiments. The xrs2
FHA allele was also introduced by targeted recombination into the YW1276 derivative YW1462, which contained the yku80
605-629 allele. The double mutant was mated to MATa wild-type, yku80
, and xrs2
strains from the genome deletion array (46), followed by sporulation and dissection to generate the strains used in Fig. 4A.
![]() View larger version (79K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 4. The Xrs2 FHA domain and the Yku80 C terminus act synergistically during NHEJ. (A) Genotypes of YW1276 derivative strains used in this figure. Letters from this table are used to designate strains in panels B to F. Strain I (xrs2 yku80 ) displayed rapid senescence and could not be used for further experiments (indicated by shading). (B and C) The yku80 605-629 xrs2 FHA double mutant (strain E) demonstrates synergistic inhibition of precise NHEJ (B) and +2 imprecise NHEJ (C) compared to the corresponding single mutants (strains B and D) in the HO(+2) suicide deletion assay as described in the legend to Fig. 2. (D) Double-mutant strain E is not temperature sensitive or hypersensitive to camptothecin (10 µg/ml), hydroxyurea (30 mM), or a 30-min exposure to 0.3% MMS. (E) Telomeric Southern blotting showing that the yku80 605-629 and xrs2 FHA mutants have wild-type telomere length. Y'-type telomeres are indicated. (F) Strains B to H are deficient in recircularization of a plasmid with a DSB in the LEU2 marker following transformation. Error bars indicate standard deviations for at least three replicates.
|
![]() View larger version (44K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. Ku80 alignment and suicide deletion assay. (A) Comparison of human and yeast Ku80 showing conserved VWA and ß-barrel core domains but little conservation of the C termini. (B) Alignment of the fungal Ku80 C terminus demonstrates a cluster of conserved amino acids between residues 605 and 619. Species shown are as follows: Sc, Saccharomyces cerevisiae; Sm, Saccharomyces mikatae; Sb, Saccharomyces bayanus; Sp, Saccharomyces paradoxus; Sku, Saccharomyces kudriavzevii; Skl, Saccharomyces kluyveri; Scas, Saccharomyces castelli; Cg, Candida glabrata; Ag, Ashbya gossypii; Kl, Kluyveromyces lactis. Numbers indicate S. cerevisiae Yku80 residues. Black shading, residues that are identical in all proteins; light gray shading, residues identical to S. cerevisiae; dark gray shading, conservative substitutions. (C) HO(+2) suicide deletion assay. Galactose-induced expression of the HO endonuclease results in deletion of the HO coding sequence and a DSB in the ADE2 marker. DSB repair by NHEJ allows cell survival, with repair in the +2 frameshift register resulting in Ade+ cells. The principal joint responsible for Ade and Ade+ colonies is shown.
|
allele were grown 2 days in SD medium lacking uracil (SD-Ura), diluted 1:1,000, and grown 2 more days in SD complete medium. Strains were then plated or spotted to nonselective, uracil-selective, and 5-FOA plates. Sensitivity to DNA-damaging agents. Camptothecin and hydroxyurea sensitivity were determined by spotting serial dilutions of yeast to media containing 10 µg/ml camptothecin or 30 mM hydroxyurea. Methyl methanesulfonate (MMS) sensitivity was determined by incubating exponentially growing cells with 0.3% MMS in 50 mM sodium phosphate buffer (pH 7.5) at 30°C for 30 min, followed by spotting of serial dilutions to SD complete plates.
Plasmid recircularization NHEJ assay. One hundred nanograms of the LEU2-marked plasmid pRS315 cut with AgeI (Roche) was cotransformed with 10 ng supercoiled pRS413 (4) marked with HIS, as described previously (6). Transformed cells were plated in parallel to a glucose medium lacking either leucine or histidine and were grown at 30°C for 3 days. Relative repair efficiency was measured as the ratio of Leu+ colonies to His+ colonies. Note that because the AgeI-induced DSB is in the LEU2 marker, cotransformation with pRS413 cannot lead to Leu+ colonies by homologous recombination.
Telomere length assessment. Telomere length was monitored essentially as described elsewhere (3). Briefly, yeast cells were grown for 40 generations in liquid YPAD. Genomic DNA was then prepared by glass bead lysis, digested with RNase A and XhoI, and probed by Southern blotting with radiolabeled poly(GT)20.
|
|
|---|
![]() View larger version (37K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. NHEJ yeast two-hybrid screen. (A) All NHEJ gene constructs were cloned by gap repair into both pOBD2 (bait) and pOAD (prey) vectors. Two independent bait isolates were arrayed in a 96-well microtiter dish. Two independent prey isolates were pooled and mated against the bait array to generate arrays of diploids containing paired bait and prey clones. (B) Schematic summarizing the two-hybrid results. Double-headed arrows indicate interactions that were detected by reciprocal bait-prey pairings. Single-headed arrows indicate interactions that were detected in only one orientation, with the arrow pointing to the prey. Arrows point to the domain responsible for the interaction as determined from the pattern of positive clones. Shading is used to indicate the previously known stronger interactions. Note that some proteins are drawn in reverse. (C) Plasmids mediating novel interactions were isolated, sequenced, and transformed into PJ694- . Two-hybrid interactions were assessed by spotting to His and Ade plates and assaying for lacZ expression by measuring ß-galactosidase activity.
|
Truncation of the Yku80 C terminus selectively impairs NHEJ.
We chose to focus first on the Yku80 C terminus. This protein region was interesting for reasons described in the Discussion. Moreover, the multiple activities of the Ku heterodimer allow separation of the functional effects of specific mutations. In these studies, NHEJ was assessed primarily by using the suicide deletion assay (Fig. 2C), (9). This assay allows for quantification of the absolute efficiency of DSB repair by NHEJ, as well as of the percentage of total repair that is imprecise in the +2 register (yielding Ade+ yeast). Complete deletion of YKU80 (yku80
) results in an approximately 50-fold reduction in total NHEJ and a >1,000-fold defect in imprecise NHEJ (Fig. 3A and B). Three NHEJ-independent Ku telomere phenotypes were also examined. First, yku80
strains are unable to grow at 37°C because of telomere deprotection (Fig. 3C) (3). Second, we tested the epigenetic silencing of a subtelomeric marker (2). When our URA3-TPE allele was used, approximately 6% of wild-type but not yku80
cells formed colonies on plates containing the URA3 counterselective drug 5-FOA (Fig. 3C). Finally, we performed Southern blotting with a telomere-specific probe, since yku80
strains show shortened Y'-type telomeres (Fig. 4E), (3).
![]() View larger version (83K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. Truncation of the Yku80 C terminus results in NHEJ-specific defects. (A) Effects of Yku80 C-terminal truncations on total NHEJ repair by HO suicide deletion. The yku80 605-629, 591-629, and 577-629 mutants showed a modest twofold reduction in total NHEJ. (B) Effects of Yku80 C-terminal truncations on +2 imprecise NHEJ by HO suicide deletion. Data are plotted as the ratio of Ade+ to total colonies. The yku80 605-629, 591-629, and 577-629 yeast strains showed a ninefold reduction in +2 imprecise events. No Ade+ events were recovered with the yku80 strain. Error bars indicate standard deviations for at least three replicates. (C) Haploid strains containing the yku80 mutations and the URA3-TPE allele were spotted to SD complete, SD-Ura, and SD 5-FOA plates. Complete plates were incubated at 37°C. Strains were also quantitatively plated to media with and without 5-FOA to determine the percentage of FOA-resistant cells (% FOAR). Unlike the yku80 and yku80 552-629 yeast strains, the yku80 605-629, 591-629, and L609A yeast strains did not show compromised growth at 37°C and were also able to epigenetically silence the URA3 marker.
|
552-629, which deleted almost the entire region present in the Yku80 two-hybrid construct that interacted with Dnl4, resulted in a loss of NHEJ approaching that of the yku80
strain (Fig. 3A and B). This mutant also displayed sensitivity to growth at 37°C and shortened Y'-type telomeres (Fig. 3C and 4E), most likely indicating that this truncation destabilizes the Ku heterodimeric ring. Mutations yku80
577-629, 591-629, and 605-629 were more informative. Each of these truncations caused a significant twofold reduction in total NHEJ and a ninefold reduction in +2 imprecise NHEJ (Fig. 3A and B). The yku80
577-629 strain was only partially temperature sensitive, while strains with the more distal deletions were not at all sensitive to growth at 37°C (Fig. 3C). This suggested that these truncations confer a partial separation of the Yku80 NHEJ and telomeric functions. Consistent with this, yku80
605-629 and yku80
591-629 yeasts were also able to induce TPE to near-wild-type levels (2.9 and 1.5% 5-FOA-resistant colonies, respectively) and showed wild-type telomere repeat lengths (Fig. 3C and 4E). Truncation of the last 10 Yku80 amino acids (yku80
619-629) had no effect on NHEJ efficiency or temperature sensitivity (Fig. 3), consistent with the fact that these residues are not conserved in other fungi (Fig. 2B). Taken together, these results point to amino acids 605 to 619 as an important determinant for Yku80 function in NHEJ, but for none of its telomeric functions. Interestingly, this region of the Yku80 C terminus is the most highly conserved among fungi (Fig. 2).
The Xrs2 FHA domain is functionally redundant with the Yku80 C terminus in NHEJ.
We hypothesized that mutation of the Yku80 C terminus caused only partial NHEJ loss because of a potential redundancy of its function. Specifically, the DNA ligase IV complex, composed of Dnl4 and Lif1, appeared to make contacts with both Yku80 and the FHA domain of Xrs2 (Fig. 1B). To examine the role of the Xrs2 FHA domain, we created an amino-terminal deletion of amino acids 1 to 125 (xrs2
FHA). This allele and the complete deletion, xrs2
, were then introduced into the yku80
605-629 and yku80
strains in all combinations (Fig. 4A). Myc-tagged derivatives of these strains were also subjected to immunoblotting, which confirmed that yku80
605-629 and xrs2
FHA were expressed at levels similar to those of their wild-type counterparts (see Fig. S4 in the supplemental material). Complete deletion of XRS2 resulted in approximately 10-fold inhibition of total NHEJ and 150-fold inhibition of +2 imprecise NHEJ (Fig. 4B and C, strain G). This large decrease was expected given the known role of MRX in NHEJ (43) but, interestingly, was less than that observed for yku80
(Fig. 4). In contrast, xrs2
FHA did not significantly impair total NHEJ and resulted in only a twofold inhibition of +2 imprecise repair (Fig. 4B and C, strain D), even less than the reductions observed for yku80
605-629 (strain B). However, the yku80
605-629 xrs2
FHA double mutant (strain E) showed a 40-fold decrease in total NHEJ and a >1,000-fold decrease in +2 events, very similar to the NHEJ phenotype of yku80
yeast and more severe than even xrs2
yeast (strains C and G, respectively). This synergism is consistent with the hypothesis that Ku and MRX have partially redundant functions in NHEJ.
To confirm these NHEJ defects by a different method, we tested the ability of our strains to recircularize a linear plasmid. All strains were cotransformed with pRS315 cut in the LEU2 marker with AgeI and a circular plasmid control that contained the HIS3 marker. Repair was measured as the ratio of Leu+ colonies to His+ colonies. The pattern of results (Fig. 4F) was the same as that seen with suicide deletion, with the yku80
605-629 xrs2
FHA strain (strain E) showing a plasmid joining defect equivalent to that of yku80
(strain C). Interestingly, the yku80
605-629 and xrs2
FHA mutants were more obviously defective in the plasmid assay, with yku80
605-629 alone now showing a 44-fold decrease in joining.
To again verify that these double-mutants selectively lost the NHEJ functions of Xrs2 and Yku80, the entire panel of mutants was spotted to plates containing 10 µg/ml camptothecin or 30 mM hydroxyurea. Camptothecin induces topoisomerase-mediated damage during replication, while hydroxyurea produces stalled replication forks. Mutants were also exposed for 30 min to 0.3% MMS, a radiomimetic leading to DSBs requiring homologous recombination for repair (24). All of these lesions require either the recombination or the checkpoint functions of the MRX complex (15, 25, 26). Deletion of XRS2 accordingly resulted in severe drug sensitivity (Fig. 4D, strain G). In contrast, xrs2
FHA did not impair MRX-mediated resistance to any of the drugs tested, even in the yku80
605-629 background (strain E). The MMS data further supported the role of the Yku80 C terminus in DSB repair, since adding the yku80
605-629 mutation eliminated the rare survivors seen in the xrs2
background (Fig. 4D).
Both MRX and Ku are required for telomere maintenance, and mutation of either complex leads to reduced numbers of telomere repeats. However, the roles of the two complexes are distinct. While the Ku complex protects the telomeres from excessive nucleolytic degradation, the MRX complex is likely involved in telomerase-based telomere elongation (7). For this reason, combined yku80
xrs2
mutants display rapid senescence and become nonviable after several generations (Fig. 4, strain I) (30). Indeed, the normal and stable growth rate ofyku80
605-629 xrs2
FHA yeast already demonstrated preservation of telomeres in this strain, and accordingly, thestrain was also able to grow normally at 37°C (Fig. 4D). Moreover, the xrs2
FHA and xrs2
FHA yku80
605- 629 mutants (strains D and E, respectively) demonstrated telomeres of wild-type length (Fig. 4E). The combined xrs2
FHA and yku80
605-629 mutations therefore confer marked separation of Ku and MRX functions, with near-complete loss of NHEJ but essentially no impairment of recombination or telomere maintenance.
Identification of Yku80 C-terminal residues important for NHEJ.
Since truncations of the C terminus of Yku80 resulted in NHEJ-specific defects, we next sought to identify the residues important for the function of this undescribed protein region. We initially performed alanine scanning of all hydrophilic amino acids between residues 578 and 618 on the hypothesis that these were most likely to be surface exposed and to mediate a protein-protein interaction. Surprisingly, however, single and even multiple alanine substitutions of these residues had little or no effect on either total or +2 imprecise NHEJ (see Table S1 in the supplemental material). Correspondingly, reexamination of the alignment of the fungal Yku80 C terminus revealed that the residues with the highest degree of conservation are in fact hydrophobic (Fig. 2B). Most notably, there are three highly conserved leucines at residues 609, 612, and 613 in the region most strongly implicated in NHEJ function by deletion analysis (amino acids 605 to 619). Therefore, we also mutated all hydrophobic amino acids in theYku80 C terminus to alanine, alone and in combinations (Fig. 5A and B; see also Table S1 in the supplemental material). Strikingly, the mutations L609A, L612A, and L613A each showed a loss of NHEJ similar to that of yku80
605-629, and changing L612 to a proline had an even greater effect (Fig. 5A and B; Table 1). As with yku80
605-629, these mutations again did not impair Ku telomere functions, indicating a specific NHEJ defect and implying normal Ku complex formation (Fig. 3C and data not shown).
![]() View larger version (42K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 5. Identification of conserved Yku80 C-terminal residues mediating NHEJ. Residues 606 to 616 were replaced individually with alanine, and the total (A) and +2 imprecise (B) NHEJ efficiencies were determined as for Fig. 2. yku80-L609A, -L612A, and -L613A mutants demonstrate total NHEJ and +2 NHEJ defects similar to those of yku80 605-629 in the XRS2 wild-type strain. Deletion of the Xrs2 FHA domain synergistically impaired total (C) and +2 imprecise (D) NHEJ in the leucine mutants and uncovered lesser defects in other residues. ND, not done; mutations were not tested in the xrs2 FHA background. Error bars indicate standard deviations for at least three replicates.
|
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. NHEJ defects correlate with loss of the Yku80-Dnl4 two-hybrid interaction
|
FHA allele into most strains with alanine substitutions for residues 606 to 619. The FHA deletion again had a synergistic effect and almost completely eliminated NHEJ when combined with the yku80-L609A and L613A mutations (Fig. 5C and D). In the xrs2
FHA background, multiple other residues in the NHEJ critical region now showed intermediate inhibition of NHEJ. The strongest effect was at the hydrophobic residue I606. Hydrophilic residues generally had a milder defect. Thus, the NHEJ-specific function of the Yku80 C terminus requires several highly conserved hydrophobic amino acids between residues 605 and 619.
We finally tested a representative set of yku80 C-terminal mutants in the yeast two-hybrid assay to establish whether their NHEJ phenotype correlated with the observation that stimulated these studies. To obtain a more quantitative assessment, the percentage of total cells that were His+ was determined by plating. The NHEJ competence of the various mutants correlated directly with the strength of the Yku80-Dnl4 two-hybrid interaction, with no outliers (Table 1). Mutants with more severe NHEJ dysfunction, such as yku80-L609A and
605-629, consistently showed complete loss of the two-hybrid interaction. Equally revealing were mutants such as yku80-D608A and T611A, which showed weakened two-hybrid interactions and a correspondingly small but measurable NHEJ defect detectable only in the xrs2
FHA background. Some mutants, such as I606A and P607A, showed complete loss of the two-hybrid interaction and clear but only partial loss of NHEJ. These and all mutants are consistent with the interpretation that interaction with Dnl4 is an important NHEJ function of the Yku80 C terminus but that the two-hybrid assay is more sensitive to Yku80 mutations than NHEJ. This is expected, because the two-hybrid assay is subject to a detection threshold of His3 expression required for colony formation, and because it used only the 90-amino-acid C-terminal region of Yku80 as opposed to otherwise intact Ku.
|
|
|---|
Our two-hybrid and mutational analyses of the Yku80 C terminus suggest that it has an important role in binding and perhaps positioning or stimulating Dnl4. All experiments, including our inability to demonstrate such binding in vitro to date, indicate that this interaction is weak, however. Thus, we cannot rule out the possibility that the observed NHEJ function of this Yku80 region is something other than direct Dnl4 binding. Alternatively, the weakness of the interaction may simply reflect its greater relevance in the context of DSB-bound proteins. Indeed, Dnl4 binding by the Yku80 C terminus is consistent with the known structure of DSB-bound Ku. Human Ku, and presumably yeast Ku, forms a ring that slides onto DNA in only one orientation with respect to the end (Fig. 6A) (42). The crystallized Ku protein lacked the C-terminal tail of Ku80, demonstrating that this region is not required for end binding. However, it is clear that the C terminus of Ku80, and not Ku70, will be oriented to face the DSB, putting it in position to promote ligation.
![]() View larger version (37K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 6. The NHEJ critical region of theYku80 C terminus. (A) The crystal structure of the human Ku70/80 heterodimer (light gray) bound to DNA (dark gray) reveals that the C terminus of Ku80 is oriented toward the DSB terminus. The C-terminal residue of the partial Ku80 protein is shown in black. (B) Schematic representation of three classes of Ku80 C termini. The -helical bundle seen in human Ku80 NMR structures is schematized in black. The DNA-PKcs-interacting region is shown in dark gray. The putative Dnl4-interacting region is shown in light gray. A possible homologous region in M. grisea is shown in white. Numbers indicate amino acid positions. (C) Helical wheel predictions for the three regions indicated in panel B.
|
-helical bundle, as seen by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), and a 12-amino-acid C-terminal region that interacts with DNA-PKcs (16). The second type, exemplified by the fungus Magnaporthe grisea, retains the same apparent helical-bundle structure but lacks the last DNA-PKcs-interacting region. Indeed, this helical bundle is conserved in most eukaryotes (18), but only organisms with DNA-PKcs homologues contain the last region (10). Intriguingly, the third class, including Saccharomyces cerevisiae and its closest relatives, does not even harbor the helical bundle.
Given this divergence of the Ku80 C terminus, it is not immediately clear if it functions analogously in all organisms. However, the Yku80 C terminus does contain a single putative
-helix that corresponds precisely to the NHEJ critical region (amino acids 608 to 615). Strikingly, this helix may be conserved just N-terminal to the M. grisea helical bundle (Fig. 6B and C). Moreover, the DNA-PKcs-interacting region at the extreme C terminus of human Ku80 is also predicted to fold as a very similar amphipathic
-helix (Fig. 6C) (18, 47), although, intriguingly, this was unstructured insolution NMR analyses in the absence of DNA-PKcs. Thus,despite their differences, all three Ku80 configurations present a similar potential protein interaction motif on the DSB side of Ku that could act by partner-induced formation and sequestration of the hydrophobic face of an amphipathic helix. This would explain our finding that both yeast NHEJ and the Yku80-Dnl4 two-hybrid interaction are dependent on three highly conserved leucines, since these would all cluster on one helical face (Fig. 6C). The especially severe defect of L612P mutation is also consistent with this model (see Table S1 in the supplemental material). It is not clear whether this pattern of putative Ku80 helices represents convergent or divergent evolution, but it is intriguing that a Ku80-DNA-PKcs-type interaction motif is also present in Nbs1 and ATRIP, where it mediates interactions with ATM and ATR, respectively (13).
Previous work identified an in vitro interaction between Xrs2 and Lif1 (5). Our studies indicate that the region encompassing the FHA domain of Xrs2 and the C terminus of Lif1 mediates this interaction. We further show its functional importance for NHEJ in vivo. It is most striking that severe NHEJ inhibition requires disruption of both this interaction between Xrs2 and Lif1 and the proposed interaction between Yku80 and Dnl4. Why might two interactions with DNA ligase IV be required? It is possible that multiple interactions are needed to accommodate the variety of DSB end configurations presented to the NHEJ machinery. Indeed, the fact that imprecise NHEJ is more severely affected by the corresponding Yku80 and Xrs2 mutations than simple religation NHEJ implies that these protein regions are especially necessary for more-complex repair events. Another possibility is that redundant binding of Dnl4 increases the kinetics and efficiency of NHEJ, which would be especially important if DNA ligase IV is the rate-limiting step. This two-contact model is also consistent with published data characterizing an inefficient microhomology-mediated end-joining (MMEJ) mechanism, which involves MRX and DNA ligase IV but not Ku (27). The Xrs2-Lif1 interaction can account for this Ku-independent role of Dnl4, while the absence of the Ku interaction could explain at least in part the inefficiency of MMEJ.
Several recent studies have addressed the role of the Xrs2/Nbs1 FHA domain in the cell. In mammalian cells, the Nbs1 FHA domain is important for nuclear focus formation and checkpoint signaling, but its role in DNA repair is unclear (38). In yeast, no definitive role for the Xrs2 FHA domain in DSB repair has been identified, and indeed, several recent studies have revealed no phenotype for xrs2 mutants lacking this domain (35, 41). Our work identifies an important NHEJ role for the Xrs2 region containing its FHA domain, but this role is robustly apparent only in the Yku80 mutant background. FHA domains bind with high specificity to phosphothreonine residues (12). We do not yet know if a similar function of the Xrs2 amino terminus mediates its interaction with Lif1, but it should be noted that the FHA domain of polynucleotide kinase 3' phosphatase interacts with the C terminus of XRCC4 (mammalian homologue of Lif1) in a manner dependent on phosphorylation of XRCC4 by CK2 (23).
Importantly, the Yku80 C terminus and Xrs2 FHA domains cannot account for the full role of Ku and MRX in NHEJ, because both the yku80
605-629 and xrs2
FHA mutants retain substantial NHEJ activity, unlike the complete gene deletion mutants. This may indicate that MRX and Ku both serve other essential functions in NHEJ. Specifically, Ku may be required for protecting ends from degradation, and MRX may be required to tether the DNA ends together (11). A nonexclusive possibility is that the putative Mre11-Yku80 interaction detected in our screen, and perhaps other interactions, may help drive formation of an NHEJ repairosome that contains both MRX and Ku. Indeed, although we have identified many protein-protein interactions involved in NHEJ, there are certainly additional interactions we did not detect. Some may be realized only during NHEJ, either because they are DNA dependent or because they require context-dependent modification of proteins. Moreover, the two-hybrid method has a sensitivity threshold that is biased toward stronger interactions. In this regard, Tseng and Tomkinson described an interaction between Dnl4/Lif1 and Pol4 in vitro (40) that was not recovered in our screen. Further biochemical work will be required to fully understand the extent of interactions between the various NHEJ proteins.
. This work was supported by the Pew Scholars Program in the Biomedical Sciences of the Pew Charitable Trusts, Public Health Service grants R01CA90911 and R01CA102563 (T.E.W.), and the Loeb Predoctoral Fellowship (P.L.P.).
Supplemental material for this article may be found at http://mcb.asm.org/. ![]()
|
|
|---|
-H2AX foci through interaction with the FHA/BRCT domain. Curr. Biol. 12:1846-1851.[CrossRef][Medline]
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»