Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Molecular and Cellular Biology, January 2007, p. 526-540, Vol. 27, No. 2
0270-7306/07/$08.00+0 doi:10.1128/MCB.00577-06
Copyright © 2007, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
Department of Molecular Genetics, Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot 76100, Israel
Received 2 April 2006/ Returned for modification 30 May 2006/ Accepted 1 November 2006
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
COP (Sec33/Ret1; 160
kDa); ßCOP (Sec26; 110 kDa); ß'COP (Sec27; 102
kDa);
COP (Sec21; 98 kDa);
COP (Ret2; 60 kDa);
COP (Sec28; 35 kDa); and
COP (Ret3; 20 kDa), as well
as the Arf1 small GTPase, which are conserved from yeast to mammals
(56). Coatomer subunits
can be divided into two subcomplexes: the B subcomplex (COPIb) composed
of the
, ß', and
subunits; and the F
subcomplex (COPIf), consisting of the ß,
,
,
and
subunits
(22,
40). Interestingly, the
subunit of COPIf shows structural similarity to components of
the clathrin adaptor, AP2
(31), while COPIb has
been suggested to be clathrin-like
(40). Clathrin is another
multisubunit coat complex involved in Golgi
apparatus-to-vacuole/lysosome transport, endocytosis, and endosomal
protein sorting (36,
37,
40,
42). The COPI coat is
responsible for the biogenesis and sorting of vesicles from the Golgi
apparatus and their delivery to the ER via retrograde transport
(38). Mutations in
coatomer components directly affect retrograde trafficking, but also
alter anterograde transport from the ER
(18,
19,
26,
32,
60). Activation of the
small GTPase, Arf1, is required for recruitment of COPI, as well as
adaptors of the clathrin coat, to membranes (for review, see references
40,
42,
53, and
56). Thus, both the COPI
and clathrin coats appear to have common structural properties and
regulatory controls.
Studies of mammalian cells have suggested an
additional function for a subset of COPI subunits upon the endocytic
pathway. Mellman and colleagues demonstrated the association of certain
COPI components with endosomes, identifying the
, ß,
ß',
, and
coatomer subunits, but not
the
and
subunits
(59). Their
association with endosomal membranes was GTP
S stimulated and
brefeldin A sensitive, indicating that COPI binding depends upon ARF
activity. Importantly, the microinjection of antibodies against
ßCOPI blocked infection by vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV), an
envelope virus that infects cells by endocytosis. As VSV must reach the
late endosome in order to enter the cytoplasm, this suggested that COPI
may be involved in early to late endosome transport. Both VSV infection
and the delivery of endogenous cargo proteins to late endosomes and
lysosomal compartments were inhibited in CHO cells either possessing a
temperature-sensitive allele of
COP (e.g., 1d1F cells) or
injected with antibodies against this subunit
(15). Likewise, Gruenberg
and colleagues found an inhibition in early to late endosome transport
in 1d1F cells and proposed the involvement of COPI in the biogenesis of
the multivesicular bodies (MVBs) in mammalian cells
(29). Furthermore, they
demonstrated that
COP and ßCOP recruitment to
endosomes requires
COP
(29) and ARF1
(30) and is lumenal pH
dependent (1). COPI was
later shown to mediate Nef-induced downregulation of the human
immunodeficiency virus viral receptor, CD4
(23). Nef binding of CD4
recruits the clathrin AP2 coat, resulting in clathrin-mediated
endocytosis. Next, Nef binds ßCOP at the early endosomes and
targets CD4 to the late endosome and lysosomal compartments in an
ARF1-dependent fashion (5,
23). More recently, we
reported that some COPI mutants are impaired in recycling of the green
fluorescent protein (GFP)-Snc1 v-SNARE from endosomes to the Golgi
apparatus in yeast cells
(51). Altogether, these
findings support the idea of a post-Golgi apparatus role for COPI in
endosomal protein sorting.
Endosomal sorting to the lysosome (in mammals) and vacuole (in yeast) consists of two principal routes. One mediates receptor internalization and downregulation via endocytosis, while the second is an integral part of the biosynthetic pathway and directs trafficking of newly synthesized hydrolases from the Golgi apparatus to the lysosome/vacuole (27). Both endosomal transport routes converge at the MVB before delivering cargo molecules to the lysosome/vacuole. Like the role for COPI in ER-Golgi apparatus retrograde transport, the requirements for protein sorting to the MVB pathway are conserved from yeast to mammals (for recent reviews, see references 28 and 46). In mammalian cells, sorting to the MVB pathway begins at the early endosome, which either matures or fuses with the late endosome and results in its appearance as a multivesicular structure (28). Transport through the MVB pathway includes protein sorting into invaginations on the surface of the endosome/MVB, subsequent intralumenal vesicle formation mediated by the MVB machinery, and fusion of the MVB with the lysosome (28, 46). Thus, the role of the MVB machinery is to sort and internalize transmembrane proteins on the limiting membrane of MVB compartment in order to incorporate them into the lumenal vesicles formed by invagination (34, 41).
Mutations in genes involved in MVB sorting and biogenesis in yeast lead to the formation of a class E vacuolar protein sorting (vps) phenotype, which is characterized by the aberrant enlargement of the late endosome exhibiting multilamellar structures (41, 47, 50) and the partial missorting of vacuolar carboxypeptidase Y (CPY) to the cell surface (50). Class E vps mutants are defective in protein sorting into, and formation of, the MVB compartment. This group belongs to a broader class of vps mutants, which encompasses those genes essential for endosomal and vacuolar protein sorting.
The molecular mechanism underlying MVB formation has been studied extensively (28, 46). Monoubiquitination marks proteins targeted for sorting into the MVB. The ubiquitinated substrate is recognized by Vps27, a ubiquitin receptor that is recruited to the endosomal membrane by phosphotidylinositol 3-phosphate [PI(3)P] and which initiates the process of MVB sorting (33, 35). Vps27 recruits the first of three endosome-associated complexes required for transport (e.g., ESCRT-I, -II, and -III) that act sequentially in order to sort the targeted protein into invaginations on the limiting membrane of the MVB (2, 3, 33). Yet, the precise mechanism that drives endosomal membrane invagination and intralumenal vesicle formation (the topological opposite to classical coat-dependent vesicle formation) remains to be defined.
As COPI is
conserved structurally and functionally between yeast and mammals and
has been shown to function upon different steps of endosomal transport
in mammalian cells, we further examined its role in endosomal protein
sorting in yeast. We first examined CPY secretion and found strong
sorting defects in mutants with mutations in COPIb (e.g.,
sec27-1, sec28
, and
sec33-1), but not COPIf (e.g.,
sec21-1, sec21-2,
ret2-1, and ret3-1). Next, we found
transmembrane proteins that normally target to the vacuole (e.g., CPS1,
Fur4, Ste2, and Ste3) accumulate at endosomes and do not reach the
vacuolar lumen in certain COPIb mutants (e.g.,
sec27-1 and sec28
). We also
observed the accumulation of an enlarged late endosome in those cells
using the lipophilic dye FM4-64. These results parallel those described
for vps mutants impaired in MVB sorting and vesicle formation
(50). Finally, we found
that Vps27 coimmunoprecipitates with all COPIb subunits and partially
colocalizes with red fluorescent protein (RFP)-tagged Sec28. These
observations lead us to propose the direct involvement of COPIb in
endosomal protein sorting to the MVB compartment in
yeast.
|
|
|---|
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. Yeast
strains used in this study
|
tail-GFP, which express STE2-GFP or
STE2
tail-GFP
(57), respectively, were
generously provided by K. Blumer (Washington University School of
Medicine, St. Louis, MO). Plasmid
pGAL
BglII-CPY[1-50]GFP, which expresses
CPY1-50-GFP, was kindly provided by O. Deloche
(Universite de Lausanne, Lausanne,
Switzerland). |
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 2. Plasmids
used in this study
|
FM4-64 labeling and visualization. Yeast cells grown to mid-log phase were stained with the lipophilic dye FM4-64 (Molecular Probes, Eugene, OR), basically as described previously (58). For endosomal staining, cells were incubated with 16 µM of FM4-64 on ice in the dark for 45 min. Afterwards, cells were washed twice with fresh medium and kept on ice prior to observation by confocal microscopy. To induce endocytosis and label the endosomal compartments, cells were transferred to 26°C for 10 min. For vacuolar staining, cells were pulsed with 32 µM of FM4-64 for 20 min in the dark at 26°C. Following the pulse, two chases of 20 min each in medium lacking FM4-64 at 26°C were performed. Labeled cells were observed by confocal microscopy.
Immunoblot assay for CPY and Kar2 secretion. Yeast cells were either plated or spotted (as 10-fold serial dilutions of cells) on YPD plates at 26°C and grown for 24 h prior to replica plating onto nitrocellulose filters (BA-S85; Schleicher and Schuell). The filters were then placed yeast side up, incubated on a fresh YPD plate, and grown for an additional day. The immunoblotting assay for CPY and Kar2 secretion was performed using standard procedures. Cells were removed by three washes of the membranes for 5 min each with phosphate-buffered saline. No cell lysis was observed on either plates or filters using this technique (data not shown). Filters were then blocked in 5% nonfat dry-milk in 0.1% Tween 20-phosphate-buffered saline for 1 h. After blocking, membranes were probed with polyclonal anti-CPY antibodies (1:1,000; gift of S. Emr, University of California, San Diego) or polyclonal anti-Kar2 antibodies (1:2,000; gift of C. Barlowe, Dartmouth University, Hanover, NH), and detected by ECL enhanced chemiluminescence, using anti-rabbit peroxidase-conjugated antibodies (1:10,000; Amersham Biosciences).
Separation of extracellular and intracellular forms of CPY. Five optical density at 600 nm (OD600) units of yeast grown to mid-log phase was incubated in 500 µl of YPD medium containing 50 mM KPO4, pH 5.7, for 1 h at 30°C. Then 5 µl of 1 M NaN3 was added, and the cell cultures were cooled on ice for 10 min. Culture samples were centrifuged to separate the cells (containing the intracellular fraction; I) from the medium (containing the extracellular fraction; E). Cell pellets were resuspended in 150 µl of spheroplast-forming buffer (50 mM Tris-HCl, pH 7.4, 1.4 M sorbitol, 2 mM MgCl2, 10 mM NaN3, freshly added 40 mM ß-mercaptoethanol, 0.15 mg/ml of Zymolase) and incubated by gentle shaking for 30 min at 30°C. Spheroplasts were lysed by the addition of 50 µl of 2% sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) and boiled for 5 min. The lysate was then centrifuged for 10 min at 20,800 x g, and the supernatant was removed for electrophoretic separation on acrylamide gels by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE). Samples taken for electrophoresis consisted of an aliquot of 0.1 OD600 U for the intracellular fraction and an aliquot corresponding to the volume of 0.4 OD600 U in culture (40 µl). SDS sample buffer was added to each sample, and the samples were separated on 8% SDS-PAGE gels. Following transfer to the nitrocellulose membranes, the blots were incubated with polyclonal anti-CPY antibodies (1:1,000; gift of S. Emr, University of California, San Diego) and proteins were visualized using ECL chemiluminescence.
Co-IP assays. Fifteen OD600 U of mid-log-phase-grown yeast was lysed for each coimmunoprecipitation (co-IP), as described previously (14). The following changes were made in that cell lysis and co-IP were performed in IP buffer (1 mM EDTA, 10 mM Tris-HCl, pH 7.5, 150 mM NaCl, 0.5% Nonidet P-40) containing protease inhibitors (leupeptin, soybean trypsin inhibitor, aprotinin, and pepstatin [each at a concentration of 10 µg/ml]) and 1 mM phenylmethylsulfonyl fluoride (PMSF). For the co-IP reaction in Fig. 5A and C, 500 µg of protein derived from the total cell lysate (TCL) was diluted in IP buffer to reach a total volume of 500 µl. For the co-IP reaction in Fig. 5B, 330 µg of protein derived from the TCL was diluted in IP buffer to reach a total volume of 300 µl. Co-IP was performed with a monoclonal anti-myc antibody (5 µl per reaction; Santa Cruz Biotechnology). Coimmunoprecipitated proteins were separated on 7.5% SDS-PAGE gels followed by transfer to nitrocellulose membranes (BioTraceNT; Pall Corp.). Detection of precipitated proteins was done using monoclonal anti-myc (1:1,000), polyclonal anti-Vps27 (1:1,000; gift of S. Emr), or polyclonal anti-coatomer (1:1,000; gift of A. Spang, Max Planck Institute, Tübingen, Germany) antisera. Proteins were detected by ECL chemiluminescence, using secondary anti-mouse and anti-rabbit peroxidase-conjugated antibodies (1:10,000; Amersham Biosciences).
![]() View larger version (73K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 5. Vps27
binds to subunits of COPIb. (A) Coimmunoprecipitation of
GFP-Vps27 with COPIb. Class E vps mutant yeast
(vps23 ) bearing multicopy plasmids expressing
myc-SEC27 (pADH-SEC27), myc-SEC28 (pADH-SEC28), or
myc-SEC33 (pADH-SEC33), together with a second plasmid
expressing GFP-VPS27 (pGFP-VPS27), were lysed and subjected to
immunoprecipitation (IP) with anti-myc antibodies. Detection of the
precipitated proteins in immunoblots (IB) was performed with anti-Vps27
(1:1,000), anticoatomer (1:1000), or anti-myc (1:1,000) antibodies.
"Vector" indicates cells transformed with an empty
vector (pAD6). , cells lacking the GFP-Vps27 protein;
+, cells producing the GFP-Vps27 protein. Samples of the TCL
are shown (50 µg protein/lane). (B) Sec33 interacts
with Vps27 in cells lacking Sec28. Wild-type (WT) yeast (BY4741), a
class E vps mutant (vps23 ), or
SEC28-deficient cells (sec28 ) bearing
multicopy plasmids expressing myc-SEC33 (pADH-SEC33) and
GFP-VPS27 (pGFP-VPS27) were lysed and subjected to
immunoprecipitation as described for panel A. (C) A control
protein, Vsm1, does not precipitate myc-Sec27. Wild-type yeast (BY4741)
cells bearing multicopy plasmids expressing myc-SEC27
(pADH-SEC27) or myc-VSM1 (pADH-VSM1), together with a second
plasmid expressing GFP-VPS27 (pGFP-VPS27), were subjected to
immunoprecipitation as described for panel A. Detection of the
precipitated proteins in immunoblots was performed with anti-Vps27
(1:1,000) or anti-myc (1:1,000) antibodies. (D)
Coimmunoprecipitation of Sec28-GFP with Vps27-myc expressed from the
genome. Wild-type yeast (W303-1a) cells bearing integrated
SEC28-GFP (GGY3), VPS27-MYC (GGY4), or both (GGY5)
were lysed and subjected to immunoprecipitation. , cells
lacking the integration; +, cells bearing the integration of
the corresponding tag. Detection of the precipitated proteins in
immunoblots was performed with anti-GFP (1:1,000) or anti-myc (1:1,000)
antibodies. Samples of the TCL are shown (50 µg
protein/lane).
|
|
|
|---|
(20) and
sec21-2
(38) cells, which are
unaffected; and sec33-1 cells, wherein the ER form of
CPY (p1-CPY) accumulates
(60). We employed an
immunoblot assay to detect CPY secretion onto nitrocellulose filters
using anti-CPY antibodies. This allows for easy and reliable detection
of general endosomal sorting defects in yeast cells
(12). This assay has been
widely used to isolate vps mutants that secrete CPY
(7). In wild-type cells,
p2-CPY is delivered to the vacuole from the Golgi apparatus, where it
undergoes maturation (to m-CPY) and serves as a proteolytic enzyme in
degradation processes. In contrast, the p2 form of CPY is partially
missorted and secreted outside the cell in vps (including
class E) mutants, which are impaired in late endosomal protein sorting
(9). By employing this
immunoblot assay, we found that sec27-1 cells
secreted CPY at levels similar to deletion mutants of the ESCRT-I
subunits (e.g., vps23
, vps28
, and
vps37
cells), as well as a deletion of the vacuolar
t-SNARE, Vam3 (16), at
26°C (Fig. 1A, B, and
E; and Table
3). We observed slightly less CPY secretion from
sec28
and sec33-1 cells (Fig.
1A). In contrast to the
COPIb mutants, neither various wild-type strains (e.g., BY4741,
W303-1a, and NY13) nor cells bearing mutations in COPIf subunits (e.g.,
sec21-1, sec21-2, and
ret3-1) secreted CPY. Although wild-type strain
SEY6210 and the ret2-1 mutant strainsecreted a small portion of CPY (perhaps reflecting some defect in
vacuolar protein sorting), the amount of the secreted protein was much
lower than that seen from sec27-1 and
vps23
cells (Fig.
1B and Table
3). Together, these
results indicate that some of COPI mutants have defects in post-Golgi
apparatus sorting and endosomal transport.
![]() View larger version (75K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. Yeast
strains with mutations in COPIb secrete CPY, but not Kar2.
(A) Wild-type (WT) yeast (W303-1a) and strains with mutations
in COPIf (sec21-2), COPIb (sec27-1,
sec28 [RDY241], and sec33-1; gifts
of R. Duden), ESCRT (vps23 , vps28 ,
and vps37 ), and vam3 were patched
onto nitrocellulose filters and grown upon solid rich medium for 1 to 2
days at 26°C. Cells secreting CPY and Kar2 were identified by
immunodetection (see Materials and Methods). Both the
vam3 and ESCRT mutants served as positive controls
for CPY secretion. (B) Various wild-type cells and COPI
mutants do not secrete CPY. Wild-type yeast (BY4741, W303-1a, NY13, and
SEY6210) and strains with mutations in COPIb (sec27-1
and ret1-3), COPIf (sec21-1,
ret2-1, and ret3-1), and ESCRT
(vps23 ) were patched onto nitrocellulose filters
and treated as described in the legend to Fig.
4A. (C) p2-CPY
is secreted into the medium from a COPI mutant. Five OD600 U
of wild-type yeast (BY4741), ESCRT (vps23 ), and COPIb
(sec27-1) was grown in YPD medium containing 50 mM
KPO4, pH 5.7, for 1 h at 30°C. Cultures
were harvested by centrifugation to separate the intracellular (I;
cells) and extracellular (E; medium) fractions. The fractions were
treated as detailed in Materials and Methods, and aliquots of each were
separated by SDS-PAGE. The positions of the precursor (p2-CPY) and
mature (m-CPY) forms of CPY are indicated. Relative amounts (in
percent) of the secreted (p2-CPY) and intracellular (m-CPY) forms of
CPY for each strain, as calculated using densitometry, are presented
below the Western blot. (D) Growth sensitivity of various
COPIb strains. Wild-type yeast (BY4741) and ESCRT
(vps23 ) and COPIb (sec27-b1,
sec28 #1 [Y01469] and sec28 #2
[RDY241]) mutant cells were grown on glucose-containing medium; and
yeast strains with a galactose-inducible SEC28 allele
(GAL-SEC28 and GAL-SEC28 vps23 ) were
maintained on galactose-containing medium prior to shifting to
glucose-containing medium for 20 h. Cells were then diluted
serially (10-fold dilutions) and plated onto solid medium. Cells were
grown at various temperatures (26°C to 37°C, as
indicated) for 2 days. (E) COPIb strains secrete different
levels of CPY. The same strains as shown in panel D were grown at
26°C on a nitrocellulose filter on a YPD plate. CPY detection
was performed as described for panel A. (F) Suppression of
SEC28 expression in glucose-containing media. Wild-type and
vps23 yeast cells bearing GAL-SEC28 (GGY1
and GGY2, respectively) were grown on either galactose- or
glucose-containing medium for 20 h, lysed, and subjected to
Western blot analysis using anticoatomer
antibodies.
|
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 3. Summary
of vacuolar protein sorting phenotypes in COPI mutants
|
mutants, but not from wild-type cells (Fig.
1C). Using densitometry,
we calculated the relative amounts of secreted p2-CPY versus
intracellular m-CPY for each cell type. In sec27-1
cells, 77% of CPY (p2-CPY) was secreted while in the
vps23
mutant, 53% of p2-CPY was found in the
extracellular fraction. Correspondingly, the amount of intracellular
m-CPY in sec27-1 cells appeared to be lower than that
in vps23
cells (23% versus 47%, respectively). This
may indicate that the defect in CPY sorting is more severe in the
sec27-1 mutant than in vps23
cells.
We also examined CPY secretion from a
sec28
deletion mutant in the Euroscarf (BY4741)
background, although we did not observe as much secretion of CPY as
strain RDY241 (sec28
#2, Fig.
1E and Table
3). Assuming that
variation might occur due to adaptive responses to the deletion of
SEC28 in either strain, we prepared a conditional
Sec28-deficient strain. We inserted an inducible GAL1 promoter
upstream of the SEC28 locus by homologous recombination. This
insertion also introduced GFP at the amino-terminal end of
SEC28. Cells were grown on galactose-containing medium prior
to shifting to glucose-containing medium to turn off SEC28
expression. Since the deletion of SEC28 is temperature
sensitive (20), we first
examined whether the GAL-SEC28 (GGY1) strain is temperature
sensitive on glucose-containing medium. We found that this strain was
unable to grow at 37°C on glucose-containing medium (Fig.
1D) but was able to grow
on galactose-containing medium (data not shown). Next, we confirmed
that Sec28 expression was absent in cells grown on glucose using
Western blot analysis (Fig.
1F). However,
GAL-SEC28 cells grown on glucose were found to secrete very
little CPY at permissive temperatures (26°C; Fig.
1E), indicating that
SEC28 depletion alone did not yield substantial CPY missorting
in our wild-type background. We next examined the contribution of Sec28
function to cells partially defective in CPY trafficking to the
vacuole. We employed a mutant deficient in an ESCRT-I component
(vps23
), which is defective in MVB protein sorting,
and created a GAL-SEC28 vps23
strain (GGY2). We found
that the double mutation led to more temperature-sensitive growth at
elevated temperatures and increased levels of CPY secretion at
26°C on glucose-containing medium in comparison to the
vps23
mutation alone (Fig.
1D). These observations
indicate a possible genetic interaction between SEC28 and
VPS23 and further support our hypothesis on the involvement of
Sec28 in vacuolar protein sorting. In addition, we found that another
SEC27 allele, sec27-b1, which was isolated as a
mutant unable to localize proteins involved in budding at bud sites
(43), secreted elevated
levels of CPY at 26°C (Fig.
1E and Table
3). Together, these
observations indicate significant phenotypic variations among COPI
mutants obtained from different sources. This could potentially explain
why COPI subunits were not previously identified as vps
mutants.
Because COPI facilitates ER-Golgi apparatus retrograde
transport, we examined COPIb mutants for retention of an ER resident
protein, Kar2, at 26°C. In wild-type cells, Kar2 is retrieved
from the Golgi apparatus back to the ER by COPI vesicles; however,
defects in retrograde transport lead to Kar2 secretion
(54). We next examined
Kar2 secretion onto filters from these cells at permissive temperatures
(26°C), under the same conditions in which CPY was secreted. We
observed that sec21-2 cells secrete small amounts of
Kar2, while sec33-1 cells secrete significantly
detectable amounts at 26°C (Fig.
1A). This contrasts with
wild-type cells, class E vps mutants, vam3
cells, and the other COPIb mutants (e.g., sec27-1 and
sec28
[RDY241]), which did not secrete Kar2. In the
case of sec27-1 and sec28
cells,
this suggests that defects in CPY protein sorting occur under
conditions in which Golgi apparatus-ER transport is
unaffected.
Vacuole-targeted transmembrane proteins accumulate on endosomes adjacent to the vacuole in certain COPI mutants. To further investigate whether vacuolar protein sorting is generally affected in COPI mutants, we applied a microscopy approach and examined the localization of a number of proteins that undergo trafficking to the vacuole (Fig. 2 and 3). We first examined the localization of transmembrane proteins known to target to the vacuole (Fig. 2 and 3A). These proteins (i.e., CPS1, Fur4, Ste2, and Ste3) reach the vacuolar lumen by means of the MVB internalization and vacuolar fusion machinery in wild-type cells, but may accumulate on the endosomal compartment adjacent to the vacuole in class E vps mutants (10, 34, 41, 55). Proteins which do not undergo internalization at the limiting membrane of MVB are delivered to the limiting membrane of the vacuole, where they remain stabilized (33).
![]() View larger version (47K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. Vacuole-targeted
transmembrane proteins accumulate on endosomes and do not reach the
vacuolar lumen in certain COPI mutants. (A) Fur4 does not
target to the vacuolar lumen in COPIb mutants. Wild-type (WT) yeast
(W303-1a) and strains with mutations in COPIf
(sec21-1, sec21-2, and
ret2-1), COPIb (sec27-1,
sec28 [RDY241], sec33-1, and
ret1-3), ESCRT (vps23 ), and
endocytosis (end4-1) were transformed with a
multicopy plasmid expressing FUR4-GFP (pADH-FUR4-GFP) and
examined by confocal microscopy. Both phase-contrast microscopy (PC)
and merged (MERGE) panels are
indicated. (B) Ste2 does not target to the vacuolar lumen in a COPIb
mutant. Wild-type yeast (W303-1a) and a COPIb mutant
(sec28 [RDY241]) were transformed with a single-copy
plasmid producing either Ste2-GFP (pRS314-STE2-GFP) or
Ste2 tail-GFP (pRS314-STE2 tail-GFP;
Ste2 tail). Strains with mutations in COPIf
(sec21-1, sec21-2,
ret2-1, and ret3-1), COPIb
(sec33-1 and ret1-3), ESCRT
(vps23 ), and END4 (end4-1)
were transformed with a multicopy plasmid expressing STE2-GFP
(pSTE2-GFP). Arrows indicate the position of endosomal compartments
adjacent to the vacuole in which GFP-tagged markers accumulate. (C)
Ste3 does not target to the vacuolar lumen in COPIb mutants. Wild-type
yeast (W303-1a) and strains with mutations in COPIf
(sec21-1, sec21-2,
ret2-1, and ret3-1), COPIb
(sec27-1, sec28 [RDY241],
sec33-1, and ret1-3), ESCRT
(vps23 ), and END4 (end4-1)
were transformed with a single-copy plasmid expressing
STE3-GFP (pSTE3-GFP) and examined by confocal microscopy.
Arrows indicate the position of endosomal compartments adjacent to the
vacuole in which Ste3-GFP
accumulates.
|
![]() View larger version (75K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. CPS1
localization is impaired, although CPY1-50GFP localizes
normally, in certain COPI mutants. (A) CPS1 does not target
to the vacuolar lumen in COPIb mutants. Wild-type (WT) yeast (W303-1a)
and strains with mutations in COPIf (sec21-2,
ret2-1, and ret3-1), COPIb
(sec27-1, sec28 [RDY241],
sec33-1, and ret1-3), ESCRT
(vps23 ), and RCY1 (rcy1 )
were transformed with a multicopy plasmid expressing GFP-CPS1
(pGFP-CPS1) and examined by confocal microscopy. Both phase-contrast
microscopy (PC) and merged (MERGE) panels are indicated. (B)
CPY-GFP localizes to the vacuole in COPIb mutants. Wild-type yeast
(W303-1a) and strains with mutations in COPIb
(sec27-1 and sec28 [RDY241]), COPIf
(sec21-1, ret2-1, and
ret3-1), ESCRT (vps23 ), and
RCY1 (rcy1 ) were transformed with a
single-copy plasmid expressing CPY1-50-GFP
(pGAL BglII-CPY[1-50]GFP) and examined by confocal
microscopy.
|
), GFP-CPS1 is not delivered
to the vacuolar lumen in COPIb mutants (Fig.
3A). Notably, in
sec27-1 and sec28
cells (those used
in Fig. 1A), GFP-CPS1 was
present on the limiting membrane of the vacuole and in large punctate
structures located adjacent to the vacuole. This contrasts with
wild-type cells or rcy1
cells, which are deficient in
early endosome-Golgi protein recycling
(24), wherein GFP-CPS1
labeling is present in the vacuolar lumen (Fig.
3A). Likewise, GFP-CPS1
localized to the vacuolar lumen in COPIf mutants (e.g.,
sec21-1, ret2-1, and
ret3-1) (Fig.
3A), suggesting that they
have no effect upon CPS1 sorting to MVB pathway. Finally, we examined
two alleles of
COP (sec33-1 and
ret1-3), a COPIb component, and found that GFP-CPS1
sorting was partially affected in sec33-1 cells, but
was not affected in ret1-3 cells. Together, these
results indicate that only mutations in COPIb subunits have an effect
upon CPS1 sorting, but they may be allele specific.
Next, we
examined the localization of GFP-tagged Fur4, a protein that resides on
the plasma membrane, but is degraded in the vacuole through the MVB
pathway (34) or recycled
through a late endosome back to the cell surface
(10). As expected,
Fur4-GFP yields labeling of the vacuolar lumen in wild-type cells, but
localizes to the plasma membrane in an endocytosis-defective mutant,
end4-1
(49) (Fig.
2A). In contrast, Fur4-GFP
is present on the plasma membrane and accumulates in intracellular
compartments in specific COPIb mutants (sec27-1 and
sec28
), as well as the vps23
(Fig.
2A) and
vps37
(data not shown) ESCRT-I mutants (Fig.
2A). A partial defect in
Fur4-GFP delivery to the vacuole was observed in
sec21-1 cells, but was not observed in the
sec21-2 COPIf and ret1-3 COPIb
mutants (Fig. 2A and Table
3), which show defects in
anterograde ER-to-Golgi apparatus transport at 26°C.
We
then examined the localization of GFP-tagged versions of Ste2 and Ste3,
which are mating factor receptors that undergo downregulation through
internalization from the plasma membrane and delivery to the vacuole by
sorting to the MVB vesicles
(34). We found that
Ste2-GFP expressed from a single-copy plasmid labeled the vacuole and
plasma membrane in wild-type cells, but was mainly concentrated in a
large punctate structure adjacent to the vacuole in the
sec28
mutant (RDY241; Fig.
2B). In contrast,
sec28
cells expressing a truncated version of
Ste2-GFP, which does not undergo internalization from the cell surface
(Ste2
tail) (57),
yielded typical plasma membrane labeling. This demonstrates that
Ste2-GFP requires internalization to accumulate at a compartment
adjacent to the vacuole in the COPIb mutant. Ste2-GFP expressed from a
multicopy plasmid in sec33-1 cells was partially
impaired in its delivery to the vacuole. In contrast, in
sec21-1, sec21-2,
ret2-1, ret3-1, and
ret1-3 cells Ste2-GFP trafficked properly. When
expressed from a single-copy plasmid, Ste3-GFP was unable to reach the
vacuole in either sec28
(RDY241) or
sec27-1 mutants (Fig.
2C), but was trafficked
properly in sec33-1 and sec21-2
cells. In end4-1 cells, which are defective in
endocytosis (49), both
Ste2-GFP (Fig. 2B) and
Ste3-GFP (Fig. 2C) labeled
the plasma membrane but were unable to be internalized, as expected.
Finally, in the control class E vps mutant
(vps23
), both Ste2-GFP (Fig.
2B) and Ste3-GFP (Fig.
2C) accumulated at
compartments adjacent to the vacuole, similar to what was observed in
the sec28
and sec27-1 COPIb
mutants.
Together, these results imply that specific mutations in COPIb subunits missort transmembrane proteins to either the limiting membrane of the vacuole or a large late endosomal compartment adjacent to the vacuole, in the case of CPS1 (Fig. 3A), or endosomal compartments adjacent to the vacuole, in the case of recycling plasma membrane proteins, Fur4 (Fig. 2A), Ste2 (Fig. 2B), and Ste3 (Fig. 2C). While our immunoblot assay (Fig. 1A, B, and E) indicated that endosomal transport is affected in some COPI mutants, the mislocalization of various vacuolar markers clearly demonstrates that a late step in vacuolar protein sorting is impaired therein.
The CPY-GFP soluble vacuolar hydrolase localizes normally in COPI mutants.
The fact that vacuole-targeted
transmembrane proteins are mislocalized in ESCRT-I and certain COPIb
mutants suggests that COPIb may participate in the process of MVB
protein sorting and/or biogenesis. To examine this further, we
determined the localization of a soluble endocytic cargo whose
transport does not depend on the MVB internalization, namely CPY.
Although CPY is secreted in part from certain COPIb mutants (Fig.
1 and Table
3), we examined whether an
intracellular fraction of this soluble vacuolar marker reaches the
vacuole. Since CPY delivery to the vacuole does not require
internalization into the MVB
(50), unlike CPS1, it has
a possibility of reaching the vacuolar lumen due to accumulation of
m-CPY even in the intracellular fraction of class E vps
mutants (2,
45). We examined CPY
delivery by monitoring the localization of a GFP-tagged and truncated
form of CPY (CPY1-50-GFP)
(17) in COPIb and other
mutants (Fig. 3B). We
found that CPY1-50GFP labeled the vacuolar lumen in both
sec27-1 and sec28
(RDY241) cells,
as well as in COPIf (sec21-1,
ret2-1, and ret3-1) mutants,
an ESCRT-I mutant (e.g., vps23
),
and rcy1
cells. Thus, while a portion of CPY is
secreted from COPIb mutants (Fig. 1A,
B, C, and E), another portion is delivered properly. These
findings are consistent with previous observations showing that CPY
processing is normal in both sec27-1 and
sec28
cells at permissive temperatures
(20,
38). The delivery of
soluble vacuolar proteins to the vacuole in COPIb mutants, in contrast
to the accumulation of transmembrane proteins on the class E
compartment therein, further supports the idea of COPIb involvement in
the MVB sorting pathway.
Certain COPIb mutants have enlarged late endosomal compartments.
We next examined whether the COPIb
mutants accumulate an enlarged late endosome (class E compartment)
similar to the established class E vps mutants
(2,
3,
50). To determine this,
we performed vital staining of vacuoles and endosomes with the
lipophilic styryl dye FM4-64
(58). Addition of FM4-64
to yeast leads to dye incorporation into the plasma membrane, which is
subsequently endocytosed and transported via endosomal transport
intermediates to the vacuole. We examined endosomal staining by
pulse-labeling with FM4-64 on ice and a short chase at 26°C, as
well as vacuolar labeling by pulse-chase incubation at 26°C
(Fig.
4A). We found that in wild-type cells, FM4-64 labeled multiple small
intracellular compartments (Fig.
4A, left panels), which
correspond to endosomes, after pulse-labeling on ice and the chase at
26°C, as previously described
(58). In contrast,
certain COPIb mutants (e.g., sec27-1 and
sec28
[RDY241]) tended to have single large punctate
structures located adjacent to the vacuole (Fig.
4A). A similar type of
labeling was observed in control vps23
cells (Fig.
4A), which are known to
have enlarged late endosomes (vps class E compartment)
(4). In pulse-chase
experiments performed at 26°C, vacuolar labeling was observed
in wild-type cells, as well as in the COPIb and vps23
mutants (Fig. 4A, right
panels). However, single large punctate structures (i.e., late
endosomes) were still observed adjacent to the vacuole in the
sec27-1, sec28
(RDY241), and
vps23
cells after the chase period. No significant
defects in FM4-64 endosomal and vacuolar labeling were obvious in
either sec33-1 or the sec21-2
mutants. Thus, altered FM4-64 labeling is exhibited in specific COPIb
mutants and the large labeled structure located adjacent to the vacuole
closely resembles the class E compartment seen in certain vps
mutants (50).
![]() View larger version (33K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 4. FM4-64
labeling of an enlarged late endosome in certain COPI mutants.
(A) FM4-64 staining of endocytic membranes in COPIb mutants.
Wild-type (WT) cells (W303-1a) and mutants in COPIf
(sec21-2), COPIb (sec27-1,
sec28 , and sec33-1), and ESCRT
(vps23 ) were grown to mid-log phase and subjected to
endosomal and vacuolar labeling with FM4-64 to visualize these
organelles (see Materials and Methods). Arrows indicate positions of
class E compartment in which FM4-64 accumulates. Phase-contrast
microscopy (PC) panels are indicated. (B) Colocalization of
FM4-64 with accumulated transmembrane proteins in COPIb mutants.
sec28 (RDY241) and sec27-1 yeast
cells expressing GFP-CPS1 or Fur4-GFP proteins were stained with FM4-64
by pulse-chase labeling at 26°C. Both phase-contrast microscopy
(PC) and merged (MERGE) panels are
indicated.
|
cells (Fig.
4B). This colocalization
was observed in all cells that had an obvious class E phenotype. This
demonstrates that the loss of COPIb function leads to the accumulation
of vacuole-bound cargoes in the enlarged late endosome. This effect is
not likely to be indirect (i.e., due to defects in retrograde ER-Golgi
apparatus transport) since the protein markers examined in this study
reached the endosomal compartments and do not accumulate at early
compartments (e.g., ER or Golgi apparatus) within the cells. However,
we cannot rule out the possibility that a COPI-mediated endosomal
recycling event might also alter protein sorting into
vesicles.
Vps27 coimmunoprecipitates with COPIb subunits.
The fact that
COPIb and class E vps mutants have a similar phenotype
suggested that COPIb may be involved directly in the MVB sorting
pathway. To address this, we examined whether COPIb subunits are able
to bind to Vps27, a protein of the late endosome/MVB that is involved
in early steps of MVB biogenesis. We performed co-IP experiments
between myc-tagged subunits of COPIb (e.g., myc-Sec27, myc-Sec28, and
myc-Sec33) and GFP-Vps27, using anti-myc antibodies
(35) (Fig.
5A). These myc-tagged constructs were functional, given their ability to
rescue their respective temperature-sensitive mutations (data not
shown). In addition, we used a vps23
mutant as the
strain background as a block in cargo internalization presumably locks
the recruited components of MVB machinery onto the endosomal membrane
(2,
3,
8,
33).
As shown in
Fig. 5A, all three tagged
COPIb subunits were expressed well and had mobilities on SDS-PAGE gels
corresponding to their expected molecular weights, although some
degradation products were observed in the lysates of myc-Sec27- and
myc-Sec33-producing cells. The latter are probably due to proteolysis
during sample preparation. Importantly, GFP-Vps27 coimmunoprecipitated
with all three COPIb subunits (Sec27, Sec28, and Sec33), but was not
evident in precipitates obtained from cells expressing vector alone.
This interaction was also observed in wild-type cells (Fig.
5B and C), indicating the
ability of Vps27 to bind to COPIb under normal conditions. Based upon
our coimmunoprecipitation data, we estimated by densitometry that 2 to
3% of cellular Vps27 was precipitated by the COPI subunits. Such a low
level of association between these COPI components and Vps27 may
indicate either a weak interaction between these proteins or,
alternatively, that only a small portion of COPI is involved in
vacuolar protein sorting. It is also possible that the interaction
between COPI components and Vps27 may not be direct, but is mediated by
another protein. A nonrelevant myc-tagged protein, Vsm1, did not
precipitate Vps27 (Fig.
5C), indicating that COPI
subunits precipitate Vps27 specifically. We note that overexpressed
GFP-Vps27, but not native Vps27, was observed in these
immunoprecipitation experiments, which could be due to low sensitivity
of the anti-Vps27 antiserum. In addition, we note that COPI
protein-protein interactions are apparently maintained in these cells,
as myc-Sec27 and myc-Sec28 were able to coimmunoprecipitate both native
and myc-Sec33 protein. To begin characterizing the molecular
requirements for the COPI-Vps27 interaction, we examined whether Sec33
could bind Vps27 in cells lacking a nonessential COPI component
(sec28
cells). As can be seen in Fig.
5B, GFP-Vps27 could be
precipitated via myc-Sec33 in sec28
cells as
efficiently as in wild-type and vps23
cells,
indicating that Sec28 is not essential for their interaction. We also
examined whether a COPIf subunit, Sec21, is able to precipitate Vps27,
but we could not observe the interaction (Fig.
5B). As the levels of
myc-Sec21 were somewhat lower than those of the COPIb subunits, this
may partly account for our inability to detect an interaction between
Sec21 and Vps27.
To examine Vps27-COPIb complex formation at endogenous levels of protein expression, we integrated a myc tag at the 3' end of VPS27 and a GFP tag at the 3' end of SEC28 in wild-type cells. As shown in Fig. 5D, Vps27-myc was able to specifically precipitate Sec28-GFP when both were expressed from their native promoters. Vps27 binding to COPIB subcomplex components further supports our hypothesis of COPI involvement in the endosomal protein sorting pathway.
Partial colocalization between a COPIb subunit and Vps27.
The physical interaction of GFP-Vps27
with COPIb subunits (Fig.
5) suggests that they
colocalize at the intracellular level. To test this, we examined the
localization of Sec28 and Sec21 tagged at their carboxy termini with
GFP and expressed from their genomic loci in wild-type cells and a
class E vps mutant (vps23
cells). In
vps23
cells, we observed punctate labeling for both
proteins which partially colocalized with FM4-64, upon pulse-chase
endosomal labeling (pulse performed on ice; short chase at
26°C) (Fig.
6A). In wild-type cells, however, the integrated forms of
both Sec28-GFP and Sec21-GFP appeared to have a more diffuse pattern of
localization than that observed in the vps23
mutant,
and we did not observe definitive colocalization with FM4-64. The
partial colabeling of Sec21-GFP with FM4-64 in vps23
cells may indicate that this COPIf component can also reside on
endosomes. In addition, we followed the localization of Sec28 tagged at
the amino terminus with GFP (GFP-Sec28) and expressed from a multicopy
plasmid. GFP-Sec28 also colocalized in part with FM4-64 in the class E
vps mutants (vps37
and
vps23
cells) and gave a basically similar pattern of
labeling (Fig. 6B, upper
panels) to that seen for Sec28-GFP. These observations demonstrate that
Sec28 resides, at least in part, on the endocytic pathway. Next, we
assessed the colocalization of GFP-Vps27 and RFP-Sec28 expressed from
multicopy plasmids in class E vps mutants
(vps4
and vps23
cells) (Fig.
6B, lower panels).
GFP-Vps27 typically labeled 1 or 2 large punctate structures (Fig.
6B, lower panels and
reference 35), and we
observed partial colocalization with RFP-Sec28 in 5 to 10% of cells
(Fig. 6B, lower panels;
see yellow arrow). We performed z sectioning of the cells
showing colocalization to be sure that the colabeled compartments
overlap (Fig. 6C). Indeed,
Sec28 partially colocalized with both endosomal markers, FM4-64 (Fig.
6C, upper panels) and
GFP-Vps27 (Fig. 6C, lower
panels), in the z sections of these cells. We noted that in
most other cells, the fluorescent RFP-Sec28 and GFP-Vps27 punctate
structures were often found adjacent to one another in wild-type and
vps23
cells (Fig.
6B, lower panels), as well
as in vps4
cells (data not shown). This suggests that
COPIb and Vps27 reside at closely juxtaposed compartments, which may
confer their physical association under certain
conditions.
![]() View larger version (30K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 6. Sec28
localizes to endosomal compartments labeled by FM4-64 and Vps27.
(A) SEC28-GFP and SEC21-GFP, expressed from
the genome, partially colocalize with FM4-64. Wild-type (WT) yeast
(BY4741) and a class E mutant (vps23 ) expressing
intragenomic SEC28-GFP (Sec28-GFP; GGY3, and GGY6,
respectively) and SEC21-GFP (Sec21-GFP; GGY7 and GGY8,
respectively) were labeled with FM4-64 and examined by confocal
microscopy. Arrows indicate the Sec28-GFP- and Sec21-GFP-labeled
endosomal compartments in which FM4-64 accumulates. (B) The
upper panels show overexpressed GFP-SEC28 partially
colocalizes with FM4-64 labeling of the endocytic pathway. Wild-type
yeast cells (BY4741) and class E mutant cells (vps23
and vps37 ) expressing GFP-SEC28 from a
multicopy plasmid (pADH-GFP-SEC28) were labeled with FM4-64 and
examined by confocal microscopy. Arrows indicate GFP-Sec28-labeled
class E compartments in which FM4-64 accumulates. The lower panel shows
that GFP-Vps27 and RFP-Sec28 partially colocalize. Wild-type yeast
cells (W303-1a) and mutant vps23 and
vps4 cells expressing RFP-SEC28 from a
multicopy plasmid (pADH-RFP-SEC28) and GFP-VPS27 expressed
from a multicopy plasmid (pGFP-VPS27) were examined by confocal
microscopy. An arrow indicates one of the colabeled endosomal
compartments in these cells, while arrowheads point out juxtaposed
RFP-Sec28- and GFP-Vps27-labeled compartments. Both phase-contrast
microscopy (PC) and merged (MERGE) panels are indicated. (C)
z sections of cells showing Sec28 colocalized with endosomal
markers. The upper panels show class E mutant cells
(vps23 ) expressing GFP-SEC28 from a
multicopy plasmid (pADH-GFP-SEC28) were labeled with FM4-64 and
examined by confocal microscopy. The lower panels show class E mutant
cells (vps23 ) expressing RFP-SEC28
(pADH-RFP-SEC28) and GFP-VPS27 (pGFP-VPS27) were examined by
confocal microscopy. z sections were taken in increments of
0.5 µm. (D) A model for COPIb in endosomal protein
sorting in yeast. Endocytosed membrane proteins Snc1 (blue) and Ste2 or
Fur4 (red) is first targeted to the early endosome (red and blue
circle) by carrier vesicles. Next, sorting of Snc1 to the
trans-Golgi apparatus and Fur4 and Ste2 to the late
(recycling) endosome occurs. Biosynthetic soluble cargo (i.e., CPY
[green]) and membrane cargo (i.e., CPS1 [brown]) are sorted from the
trans-Golgi apparatus to the late endosome (large red and
brown circle) as well. MVB biogenesis and protein sorting therein are
mediated in a COPIb- and ESCRT-dependent manner (see Discussion).
During MVB biogenesis, intralumenal vesicles (small brown and red
circles) are delivered to the vacuolar lumen where they are
degraded. COPI indicates ER-Golgi and intra-Golgi apparatus
retrograde transport steps regulated by this coat complex.
COPII indicates the ER-Golgi apparatus anterograde transport
steps regulated by this coat complex. RET indicates the
retromer complex involved in late endosome-trans-Golgi
recycling. Recycled Fur4 and, possibly, Ste2 are delivered to the
plasma membrane by secretory vesicles derived from late
endosomes.
|
|
|
|---|
), like class E vps mutants
(6,
50), secrete a portion of
CPY (Fig. 1A, B, C, and E;
and Table 3) and
accumulate an enlarged late endosome/class E compartment labeled by
FM4-64 (Fig. 4) in which
membrane proteins destined to reach the vacuolar lumen (i.e., CPS1,
Fur4, Ste2, and Ste3) accumulate (Fig.
2,
3A, and
4B). In
sec33-1 cells; however, we observed somewhat milder
effects on endosomal protein sorting and FM4-64 labeling (Fig.
2 and
4). This may be due to
defects in ER-Golgi apparatus transport, as described previously for
sec33-1 cells at permissive temperatures
(60). Indeed, we also
observed a deficiency in GFP-Snc1 plasma membrane localization in this
mutant, unlike in sec27-1 and sec28
cells (51). On the other
hand, the interaction seen between myc-Sec33 and GFP-Vps27 (Fig.
5) implies the direct
involvement of this
COP ortholog in endosomal protein sorting.
The participation of Sec33 in endocytic trafficking is also supported
by studies performed with mammalian cells
(29).
Using two
different CPY secretion assays, we detected general defects in
endosomal protein sorting in certain COPIb mutants (Fig.
1A, B, C, and E). While
the results of these assays do not point out a specific defect in
endosomal transport, subsequent studies utilizing fluorescent
protein-tagged markers and the fluorescent dye FM4-64 suggest that a
late step in vacuolar protein sorting is affected in COPIb mutants
(Fig. 2,
3A, and
4). Earlier work in yeast
supports this view, as GFP-Snc1 recycling from early endosomes to the
Golgi apparatus is also affected in COPIb mutants, as shown by us
recently (51). GFP-Snc1
was found to be more highly enriched on the bud plasma membrane in
certain COPIb mutants and in an ESCRT mutant than in wild-type cells.
This further illustrates a phenotypic similarity between the COPIb
mutants (in particular sec27-1 and
sec28
) and the class E vps mutants (i.e.,
vps28
, vps23
, and
vps37
cells) tested by us and leads us to suggest a
role for COPIb in the late endosomal protein sorting. This is supported
by ancillary studies in yeast that previously demonstrated impaired
FM4-64 staining in arf1 mutants and suggested a requirement
for Arf1 in endosomal transport
(25,
61). If Arf1 is also
required for a post-Golgi function of COPI, as predicted from these
studies, then its direct involvement in the MVB pathway should be
examined. Thus, multiple lines of evidence implicate both Arf and COPI
function in post-Golgi apparatus transport in yeast, as well as
mammals.
To determine whether components of the MVB machinery and
COPIb interact, we performed a pull-down assay between the
MVB-associated protein, Vps27, and tagged COPIb subunits. We found that
all COPIb components bind Vps27 in both wild-type cells and a
vps23
mutant, suggesting that these proteins may form
a complex in yeast (Fig.
5). However, Sec28 is
probably not necessary for COPI-Vps27 complex formation (Fig.
5B). At this point, it
does not appear that the COPIf subunit, Sec21, is able to interact with
Vps27, although the low expression levels of this protein may have
obscured the result (Fig.
5B).
In experiments designed to reveal whether components of the MVB machinery and COPI interact, we found partial colocalization between Sec28 and two endosomal markers, FM4-64 and GFP-Vps27 (Fig. 6B, lower panels). Colabeling was observed in a small number of cells (5 to 10%), while most others showed a close juxtaposition of Sec28 and either FM4-64- or Vps27-labeled compartments. This result may indicate that Sec28 is only loosely associated with endosomal compartments, which is supported by the low level of interaction seen between Vps27 and Sec28 in immunoprecipitation experiments (Fig. 5). Thus, we predict that certain COPI components act prior to MVB formation, perhaps, at the level of late endosome-MVB protein transport (see model in Fig. 6D). Further studies will be required to resolve this issue.
COPI is not the first vesicle coat shown to be required for multiple intracellular transport pathways. Earlier studies demonstrated that clathrin and clathrin adaptor proteins are responsible for transport between various secretory and endocytic compartments that bud vesicles from the plasma membrane, trans-Golgi apparatus, and endosomes (36, 37, 40, 42). Clathrin recruitment to membranes is determined by the specific type of adaptor protein involved. Among them are the classical clathrin adaptors AP1, AP2, AP3, and AP4 and alternate adaptors, like GGA and Hrs/Vps27 (40, 42). Interestingly, a distinct structural similarity between AP2, which mediates endocytosis, and the COPIf subcomplex was recently proposed (31, 40). Thus, COPI, like clathrin, may make use of alternate adaptor proteins (e.g., Vps27) to confer endosomal protein sorting.
Vps27 contains a FYVE domain that binds to PI(3)P on endosomal membranes (42) and a ubiquitin-interacting domain (UIM) that recognizes ubiquitinated cargoes destined for vacuolar lumen and sorts them into the intralumenal vesicles that form on the limiting membrane of MVBs. Vps27 also contains a clathrin-binding motif, and its mammalian homolog, Hrs, is a clathrin adaptor that binds directly to the ß-propeller domain on clathrin (48). Such ß-propeller domains (or WD-40 repeats) are also present in the Sec27 and Sec33 COPIb subunits (21, 40). The similar structural makeup between the clathrin-Hrs complex and the COPIb-Vps27 complex, described here, suggests that the latter may constitute a novel coat. In that case, Vps27 might function as an alternate adaptor (instead of COPIf) in the COPIb clathrin-like coat. While the role for a Vps27-COPIb interaction is not well understood, it may lead to the delivery of ubiquitinated cargo to Vps27 and subsequent MVB formation. Thus, we postulate a post-Golgi apparatus role for COPIb in the passage of cargo from late recycling endosomes into the MVB (Fig. 6D). These could be the same compartment, since the resolution of yeast endosomal compartments is somewhat limited.
According to morphological studies, class E
vps mutants accumulate tubular or stacked membranes to
constitute a compartment that either precedes or gives rise to the MVB
(47). Assuming the
existence of such a morphologically distinct endocytic compartment
(Fig. 6B), we suggest that
COPI could be needed for protein transport into MVBs. While the
specific role of COPI in protein sorting to MVBs is not known, there
are two likely possibilities. The "classical" view
would be that COPI functions independently of the MVB machinery in the
delivery of carrier vesicles (containing Fur4, Ste2, Ste3, and CPS1)
from the late endosome to the MVB (see model, Fig.
6D). This view is
supported by studies showing a distinct localization pattern for either
Vps27 (a marker of MVBs) or Sec28 and only partial colocalization (Fig.
6B, lower panels).
Moreover, the turnoff of SEC28 expression in the
vps23
mutant leads to enhanced CPY secretion (Fig.
1E), implying an additive
synthetic effect. Alternatively, the role of COPIb might be different
from the accepted role of COPI in vesicle biogenesis. Given the similar
phenotype seen between ESCRT and certain COPIb mutants (Fig.
1 to
4 and see reference
51) and the physical
interaction between Vps27 and Sec28 (Fig.
5), perhaps COPIb
participates in intralumenal vesicle biogenesis and sorting on the
limiting membrane of the MVB. The Vps27-COPIb complex may then
facilitate cargo recognition and, thus, play a role in protein sorting
to, or biogenesis of, the MVB. Based upon our experiments, however, we
cannot exclude the alternate possibility that COPI is involved in the
transport of components from early to late endosomes, which somehow
restricts protein sorting into the MVB. Finally, COPI may be involved
in multiple steps of endosomal transport, similar to what is proposed
for the class E vps protein, Vps4
(62). Our study supports
previous findings in mammalian cells and shows for the first time an
involvement for COPIB subcomplex components in late endosomal protein
sorting in yeast.
This work was supported by grants to J.E.G. by the Minna James Heineman and Minerva Foundations, Germany. J.E.G. holds the Henry Kaplan chair in Cancer Research.
Published ahead of print on 13 November 2006. ![]()
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»